Ancient Symbols, Modern Fashion: The Origins of the Iconic Witch Hat

The tradition of witch hats has a long and mysterious history that dates back centuries. While today's image of a witch typically includes a pointed hat with a wide brim, the origins of this iconic accessory are not quite as clear-cut as one might expect. One theory suggests that the association between witches and pointed hats may have originated from the European witch hunts of the 15th to 18th centuries. During this dark period in history, women accused of witchcraft were often depicted wearing pointed hats in illustrations and artworks. These hats were believed to be a symbol of the supernatural powers possessed by witches. However, the link between witches and pointed hats can be traced back even further.

Paper done for my senior History Seminar class at Indiana University Southeast in Spring 2014. Theme of the paper was history and memory; basically says to describe a certain historical event and how it is remembered. My main focus was the early modern European witch trials and witches how they were depicted in art and popular culture and they survived into modern times. My main point was that female witches were presented in three archetypes in early modern art: the hag, the seductress, and the inverted woman. I showed this through the various paintings and how said paintings reflected descriptions from the Malleus Maleficarum (The Witches' Hammer) and the Compendium Maleficarum and how they survived into modern popular culture. Please note that this was an undergraduate project. Both my writing style and research methods were very basic at the time.

Positing the womb as a kind of Pandora s Box, classical and medieval antifeminist tropes fed into a coherent, elite discourse of the seductions and pollutions of witchcraft being firmly rooted in phlegmatic, feminine physiology. Just setting out on her nefarious career as seductive enchantress and horrific nemesis, the adolescent witch in this image represents the quintessential siren, irresistibly calling men s virtue to its demise.

However, the link between witches and pointed hats can be traced back even further. In ancient times, the conical shape was often associated with power and authority. Egyptian depictions of their gods and goddesses often showed them wearing conical headdresses, signifying their divine status.

Where Did the Witch's Hat Come From? The Checkered Past of a Pointy Icon

In this essay, I deal with the Welsh national costume for women as a possible source and inspiration for what is now the familiar image of the Witch's hat, and delve into the ale-wives' tall hat, a millinery device to advertize their wares in crowded markets and street fairs. The 17th and 18-centuries' positive fashion influences on

Related Papers

Yvonne Owens. Abject Eroticism in Northern Renaissance Art: The Witches and Femmes Fatales of Hans Baldung Grien. Foreword by Joseph Leo Koerner. London & New York, Bloomsbury. 2020. 312 pages. 47 Illustrations. Hardcover. ISBN-10 : 1784537292, ISBN-13 : 978-1784537296

Hans Baldung Grien, the most famous apprentice and close friend of German artist Albrecht Dürer, was known for his unique and highly eroticised images of witches. In paintings and woodcut prints, he gave powerful visual expression to late medieval tropes and stereotypes, such as the poison maiden, venomous virgin, the Fall of Man, 'death and the maiden' and other motifs and eschatological themes, which mingled abject and erotic qualities in the female body. Yvonne Owens reads these images against the humanist intellectual milieu of Renaissance Germany, showing how classical and medieval medicine and natural philosophy interpreted female anatomy as toxic, defective and dangerously beguiling. She reveals how Hans Baldung exploited this radical polarity to create moralising and titillating portrayals of how monstrous female sexuality victimised men and brought them low. Furthermore, these images issued from-and contributed to-the contemporary understanding of witchcraft as a heresy that stemmed from natural 'feminine defect,' a concept derived from Aristotle. Offering new and provocative interpretations of Hans Baldung's iconic witchcraft imagery, this book is essential reading for historians of art, culture and gender relations in the late medieval and early modern periods.

Hans Baldung Grien, the most famous apprentice and close friend of German artist Albrecht Dürer, was known for his unique and highly eroticised images of witches. In paintings and woodcut prints, he gave powerful visual expression to late medieval tropes and stereotypes, such as the poison maiden, venomous virgin, the Fall of Man, 'death and the maiden' and other motifs and eschatological themes, which mingled abject and erotic qualities in the female body.

Images of Sex and Desire in Renaissance Art and Modern Historiography edited by Angeliki Pollali, Berthold Hub

In 2007, the Städel Museum presented ‘Witches’ Lust and the Fall of Man: the Strange Fantasies of Hans Baldung Grien.’ Curated and documented by Bodo Brinkmann, the show exhibited Baldung’s ‘Witch’s Sabbath’ works alongside his ‘Fall of Man’ themed images. This juxtaposition gave an overwhelming impression of the threatening allure with which Baldung imbued his graphic, nude representations of the dangerous, eroticized, feminine body. For the sixteenth-century Northern humanists who were the primary clients and collectors for these works, it seems that erotica just wasn’t sexy without the implicit, deeply affective threat of imminent physical and moral danger. Positing the womb as a kind of “Pandora’s Box,” classical and medieval antifeminist tropes fed into a coherent, elite discourse of the seductions and pollutions of witchcraft being firmly rooted in phlegmatic, feminine physiology. One image among Baldung’s idiosyncratic oeuvre stands out, however, as embodying a stunning range of discourses, emblems and tropes informing Renaissance ideas around toxic, feminine physiology and Woman’s ‘natural’ ability to inflict her fatal ‘witchcraft’ through sex. The youthful woman of a highlighted pen and ink drawing created in 1515, most often recognized by the title of The Witch and Dragon (Fig. 1), presents a comprehensive ‘buffet’ of sixteenth-century medical and theological figures informing the idea of the dangerous, female, sexual ingénue. Just setting out on her nefarious career as seductive enchantress and horrific nemesis, the adolescent ‘witch’ in this image represents the quintessential siren, irresistibly calling men’s virtue to its demise.

Baldung’s figurations of blood and fire, feminine hair, and the feminine body as poisonous vessel, negotiate this multivalent semiotics with both irony and verisimilitude. Within the complex codification that relies upon Death/Menstruation as the hermeneutic of the Fall, the Fall itself is presented as premier among Woman’s natural and inevitable maleficia. The dominant role Baldung’s witch takes in the production of visible maleficium echoes Hugh of St. Victor, who quotes from Augustine, and who is in turn echoed in the Malleus Maleficarum. Hugh paints Woman’s concupiscence conventionally, as the result of constitutional ‘weakness’ and ocular desire; the precipitous Fall of Man results from the Devil’s successful appeal to the lustful feminine gaze, as per the Augustinian trope. In the assertion that feminine malice outstrips even that of the Devil, Hugh glossed upon Augustine’s historical reading of Holy Scripture. This interpretation includes the punitive concepts of female concupiscence in bringing about the debasement of “mortal corruption” afflicting corporeal flesh through the Fall.

Preternature, Vol. 3, No. 1, 2014

"Scholarship on fifteenth- and sixteenth-century discourses of witchcraft has not focused to any great degree on the connection between the persecution of Jews and that of witches in Germany during this period, though the construction of Jews as Saturn-ruled, melancholic, phlegmatic, and physiologically toxic contributed much to the debates on witches. Typed according to simi- lar figures of “pollution,” Jews and witches were subjected to similar court procedures and suf- fered comparable “cleansings,” tests, and tortures at the hands of the Inquisition. This article argues that such concepts of the “polluted blood” of women, witches, Jews, and effeminate men may have influenced the witchcraft iconography of the sixteenth-century artist of Strasbourg, Hans Baldung Grien (1484/86–1545)."

The construction of ‘sorcerers’ in the Formicarius, Malleus Malificarum, Die Emeis and other treatises presented a comparatively impoverished imagery, whereas imaging the male victims of feminine witchcraft, like the harridan-ridden Aristotle, the mortified Adam, or the stable groom victimized by hippomanes, came near to approaching the affective, abject power of feminized witch iconography—which is to say, the naked and eroticized feminine body. More importantly, descriptions of male witches in the Malleus were based on specific, formulaic or ceremonial acts and not on grand theories of Natural Philosophy, which painted pictures of polluted physicality or sexually corrupted essential nature. Passages dealing with elite, masculine magic tended to present technical, imagistically boring reading compared to the richer, more dramatically detailed, sensationalistic sections on witches. They feature as less dramatic subjects for visual interpretation with far fewer classical antecedents and a far less universal symbol set. The closest exemplars of masculine iniquity, or ‘pollution,’ were to be found in the tropes surrounding ‘cuckolds,’ Jewish males, and addictive, ‘Faustian’ magicians – men who had lost control to the devil or his prime agent, Woman. And even these tropes relied, for their effect, upon the assignment of ‘effeminate’ attributes and the emotive language of contamination or pollution. Male witches deemed culpable for the usual, feminine stamp of maleficium were figured as woman-like in that they were constructed as ‘weak minded,’ or as ‘fools’ subject to demonic delusions and folly

Paper done for my senior History Seminar class at Indiana University Southeast in Spring 2014. Theme of the paper was history and memory; basically says to describe a certain historical event and how it is remembered. My main focus was the early modern European witch trials and witches how they were depicted in art and popular culture and they survived into modern times. My main point was that female witches were presented in three archetypes in early modern art: the hag, the seductress, and the inverted woman. I showed this through the various paintings and how said paintings reflected descriptions from the Malleus Maleficarum (The Witches' Hammer) and the Compendium Maleficarum and how they survived into modern popular culture. Please note that this was an undergraduate project. Both my writing style and research methods were very basic at the time.

Journal of Literature and Art Studies

Witches’ Sabbath offers an overload of the emblematic characteristics which were attributed to witches during the early modern period, underpinned by the complete nudity of the witches. Naked witches were not often depicted in the illustrations of respectable, cautionary literary works concerning witches, hence this artistic choice on Baldung's part is a rather innovatory. Interestingly only a year after the unveiling of Witches' Sabbath in 1510, Die Emeis - which preocuppied itself with the Lenten sermons of Johann Geiler von Kaysersberg - was published in Strasbourg similarly depicting naked witches. Although we cannot say whether the inclusion of naked witches in Die Emeis was solely the result of Baldung’s depiction, it is very likely that Geiler would have been familiar with Baldung's work due to its popularity and this woodcut could have indeed influenced his own opinions and artistic choices. Whether Baldung intended his woodcut to not only reflect a “real-life” representation of witches but, more importantly, influence how they would be depicted by their persecutors in the future is debatable. Much of the debate surrounding this piece centres on this point: was it Baldung's intention to realistically depict witches or should Baldung’s work be viewed as satirical. Either way, there is much that this woodcut can tell us about what those who genuinely believed in the existence of witches and the way fear of witchcraft was constructed for public consumption.

Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.

RELATED PAPERS

Early Modern Bodies

MA Dissertation: Distinction

O SURGIMENTO DA IMAGEM DA BRUXA NAS ARTES VISUAIS: BRUXARIA E SEXUALIDADE NAS OBRAS DE ALBRECHT DÜRER E HANS BALDUNG GRIEN

O SURGIMENTO DA IMAGEM DA BRUXA NAS ARTES VISUAIS: BRUXARIA E SEXUALIDADE NAS OBRAS DE ALBRECHT DÜRER E HANS BALDUNG GRIEN

This belief in the power of the conical shape may have influenced the association between witches and pointed hats. Additionally, some sources suggest that the association between witches and pointed hats can be attributed to a misinterpretation of traditional women's headgear. In medieval Europe, women often wore headdresses featuring a long, pointed peak called a "hennin." These distinctive hats were fashionable at the time and typically adorned with veils and other decorative elements. However, over time, these headdresses may have been associated with witchcraft due to their unique shape, leading to the development of the iconic witch hat. While the true origin of the tradition of witch hats remains somewhat elusive, it is clear that they have become an enduring symbol in popular culture. The pointed hat is now instantly recognizable as an emblem of witchcraft and magic. Whether influenced by the witch hunts, ancient Egyptian customs, or a misunderstanding of medieval fashion, the witch hat has become an iconic accessory associated with Halloween and spooky folklore worldwide..

Reviews for "From Hocus Pocus to High Fashion: The Evolution of Witch Hats and their Origins"

1. John - 2/5:

I found "Where did the tradition of witch hats originate" to be quite disappointing. The article promised to explain the origin of witch hats, but it only provided a brief and shallow overview. I was hoping for a more in-depth exploration of the historical and cultural context behind the tradition, but it fell short. The writing seemed rushed and lacked detail, leaving me unsatisfied with the information provided.

2. Sarah - 3/5:

While "Where did the tradition of witch hats originate" touched on the topic, it failed to fully answer the question in a comprehensive manner. The article briefly mentioned a few theories without providing substantial evidence to support them. It would have been helpful to delve deeper into the cultural significance of witch hats in different time periods and regions. Overall, the article felt incomplete and left me wanting more concrete information.

3. David - 2/5:

I was quite disappointed by "Where did the tradition of witch hats originate." The author seemed to lack a clear focus and the article jumped between different theories without providing a definitive answer. The writing itself was confusing at times, making it difficult to follow the author's train of thought. I had hoped for a well-researched and concise explanation, but unfortunately, this article did not deliver.

4. Emily - 1/5:

I would not recommend "Where did the tradition of witch hats originate." The article was poorly written and poorly researched. It seemed like the author simply compiled a few random theories without thoroughly investigating their validity. Additionally, the lack of citations or references made it difficult to trust the information presented. Overall, it was a waste of time and provided little valuable insight into the topic.

Witch Hat Origins: Legends, Folklore, and Reality