Planning a Pagoda Wedding When it comes to planning a wedding, there are many different styles and themes to choose from. One unique option that couples may consider is a Pagoda wedding. A Pagoda wedding is a traditional and cultural ceremony that takes place in a Pagoda, a type of tower-like structure found in many Asian countries. The first step in planning a Pagoda wedding is to find the perfect location. Pagodas can be found in various places such as parks, gardens, or even on private properties. It is important to choose a Pagoda that has enough space to accommodate all the guests and provides a picturesque backdrop for the ceremony.
Has the Mt Ebal “Curse tablet” Defeated the Historical Criticism of the Old Testament and Proved the Bible?
Last year a band of scholars caused a furore as they revealed the 3200-year-old Mt Ebal “Curse Tablet”, which would revolutionise the study of the Bible and ancient Israel. After much waiting, they published a journal article on their find where they argued for their conclusions. [1] The scholars claim that they found a lead tablet that they can read and decipher. They claim it is a curse tablet written in Hebrew, that mentions YHWH, the God of the Israelites and the Old Testament. If true, these claims would push back the emergence of Hebrew by about two hundred years, and it would be the oldest inscription within Israel that mentions YHWH by centuries. The scholars have shared their findings and conclusions very liberally on popular-level apologetic and biblical social media channels.[2]
I am not as confident as they are about the significance of this find. Here are six reflections on this article and the controversy it has caused.
1. A Worthwhile Find
The first thing to say is that it is a find worth studying. The authors have convinced me that a piece of folded-up lead at an ancient religious site is worth studying and any new data that may arise is worth bringing to light.
2. Solid Dating Methodology
The dating of the tablet is based on solid methodology. In dating the tablet, they have done good archaeological work.
3. Confident Conclusions Despite Methodological Problems
The methodological problems with the scans of the lead tablet aren’t reflected in the rhetoric of the team’s conclusions. For example, the letters the authors find in the scans are on the inside of the folded tablet. I would think that no matter how sophisticated and powerful the techniques are used to see inside the folded tablet, whatever we see inside the tablet would be a reconstruction at best and guesswork at worst.
Additionally, the images were obtained by X-ray Tomographic (XCT) measurements. The authors admit, “In general, XCT of lead objects is a challenging task because of the strong scattering of X-ray photons and the high attenuation of X-rays by lead.”[3] And “Due to the distortion of the tomographic reconstruction by scattered photons, it is difficult to determine the actual location of the letters.”[4]
Granted, they employed various techniques to reduce the challenges of using XCT measurements in this context. But, given these candid admissions about the difficulty of the task, I would think they would lead the authors to make far more modest claims. I would expect them to be more restrained about what can be seen in the tablet, what data can be extracted from what can be seen and what conclusions can be made from said data. But, in their conclusions, I don’t see that warranted restraint.
4. Letters? Yeah, nah
The article has many photos of what the authors claim are inscribed letters. When I saw these photos, I found myself repeating the oft-used Aussie idiom, “Yeah, nah.” In other words, I couldn’t see the letters they saw; therefore, I’m not convinced we can find the divine name or any other words in this tablet.
5. Alphabet Soup
The authors state that “The scribe wrote in different directions: left to right, right to left, top to bottom, bottom to top, and in boustrophedon order” (“as the ox plows”).[5] They provide a drawing with the letters on the tablet numbered in order of reading. But they don’t offer any reasons for this reading.
Even if all the letters they say there are actually there, to my eyes it still just seem to be nothing more than a jumble of letters. If an interpreter does see the logic in the flow of the text that logic needs to be demonstrated and not just stated, as the authors have. To claim to have found, in an alphabet soup, a curse that uses the divine name and has a chiastic structure is misleading.[6]
6. Irresponsible Claims
Some of the authors’ claims based on this inscription are incredibly irresponsible. Even if everything they say about the tablet is true, it doesn’t follow that this proves that Moses wrote the Pentateuch, and the documentary hypothesis is wrong. This table has no bearing on Moses’s historicity or whether he wrote the Pentateuch. Even if everything the authors claim is true, the best we can say is that we have evidence of writing in ancient Israel that predates our previous oldest Hebrew inscription at Khirbet Qeiyafa by two centuries.
It also doesn’t follow that this tablet proves the historicity of Joshua and the biblical conquest. If the authors’ claims are accurate, the location it was found in was probably cultic (related to worship). This gives us another small piece of evidence in arguing for the cultic nature of the Mt Ebal site. This small piece of evidence converges with the biblical account of Israel’s worship at Mt Ebal in Joshua 8.[7] But notice my argument; I am trying to be cautious in my conclusions because the evidence they put forward demands such caution. But the authors have not been careful in their conclusions. This is why I think their claims are irresponsible.
Why This Matters
Here is why as an evangelical pastor I wrote this article: the authors’ overblown claims hurt Bible believers; they don’t help them. Imagine the teenager who watches a YouTube clip where one of the authors of this article makes some of their egregious claims.[8] The teenager then takes a course at uni where this find and the authors’ claims are analysed. The young Christian finds that the claims are bogus and, because of this discouraging conclusion, questions other beliefs they have. This scenario is not far-fetched. At least every few months, I chat with young Christians who have been told misleading historical information about the Bible, only to find that this information is untrue. I then talk with them about what we can responsibly say about the Bible and its historicity, which for an ancient document, is quite a lot.[9]
In the last few years, I have been studying the archaeology and history of ancient Israel. When I started out, I was gobsmacked by how the claims by archaeologists and historians of all stripes, sceptical and conservative, were at odds with the facts on the ground, or even the majority of scholarship. It is good for Christian leaders and evangelists to be aware of this and to do some fact checking. We don’t need to rely on spurious archaeology and bogus conclusions to bolster our confidence in the reliability of the Bible. [10]
[1] Scott Stripling, Gershon Galil, Ivana Kumpova, Jaroslav Valach, Pieter Gert van der Veen and Daniel Vavrik, “‘You are Cursed by the God YHW:’ an early Hebrew inscription from Mt. Ebal.” Heritage Science, volume 11:105.
[2] For example see, Scott Stripling on Sean McDowell’s show: Dr. Sean McDowell, “Oldest Hebrew Writing? Mt. Ebal Curse Tablet (Revisited)”. YouTube video. 12 th May 2023. See also Associates for Biblical Research, “CURSED! The Mount Ebal Curse Tablet (Part One): Digging for Truth Episode 200”. YouTube video. 1 st May 2023.
[3] Stripling et al., “You are Cursed by the God YHW”. 4.
[4] Stripling et al., “You are Cursed by the God YHW”. 4.
[5] Stripling et al., “You are Cursed by the God YHW”. 7.
[6] Stripling et al., “You are Cursed by the God YHW”. 21.
[7] For more discussion on the archaeology of Mt Ebal and its connections to the Bible see Ralph K. Hawkins, The Iron Age I Structure on Mt. Ebal, (Indiana: Eisenbrauns).
[9] For historians that argue for the historicity of the Old Testament see Kenneth A. Kitchen, On the Reliability of the Old Testament. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans); Bill T. Arnold and Richard S. Hess (eds.), Ancient Israel’s History: An Introduction to Issues and Sources. (Grand Rapids: Baker).
[10] I would like to thank Professor William Schneidewind (UCLA) and Lawson Stone (Asbury Theological Seminary) for giving feedback on an earlier version of this article. All issues with the final product are mine!
Hans Kristensen is blessed to be saved by grace alone. He loves calling Kate his wife, Emma, Niels and Elijah his children and Marsfield Community Church his church. Hans loves anything to do with guitar and basketball. He is pursuing a bachelor of Ancient History, majoring in the archaeology, and history of Israel and the Hebrew Bible at the Australian Catholic University.
More Thoughts on the Lead Tablet from Mt. Ebal
There are a few topics in biblical archaeology that I follow closely, including the excavations at Shiloh (have they found the tabernacle platform?) and el-Araj (have they found the lost city of Bethsaida?), as well as any publication by Lorenzo Nigro and his Italian-Palestinian team from Jericho (there are frustratingly few!). Another artifact that I’m following is the lead tablet from Mt. Ebal, which was in the news again this past week, as the most recent issue of the Israel Exploration Journal contained three articles about it.
It is important to choose a Pagoda that has enough space to accommodate all the guests and provides a picturesque backdrop for the ceremony. Once the location is finalized, the next step is to choose the date and time of the wedding. Pagoda weddings are often held in the early morning or late afternoon, as these times offer the most pleasant weather and lighting conditions.
The Lead Tablet: A Review
As background, in the 1980’s, Israeli archaeologist Adam Zertal excavated a rectangular, nearly square alter on Mt. Ebal which was constructed of large, unhewn field stones and which dated to the 13 th century BC. 1 It bore traces of ash and the bones of Levitical sacrificial animals. Beneath this rectangular altar, was an earlier, circular alter, which also contained ash and animal bones. Late Bronze Age pottery and a scarab from Thutmose III (ca. 1506-1452 BC) were also discovered near the altar. 2 Some scholars believe that the round circular altar may be Joshua’s altar, mentioned in Joshua 8:30.
The altar/cultic structure on Mt. Ebal. An earlier, circular altar was discovered beneath at the at the exact geometric center. It may be Joshua’s altar. Photo: zstadler / Wikimedia Commons / CC BY-SA 4.0
In 2019, a team led by Dr. Scott Stripling of the Associates for Biblical Research, was granted permission by the appropriate authorities to resift and wet-sift the dump piles of material from Adam Zertal’s excavations. This led to the discovery of a small, folded lead tablet approximately the size of a folded business card, which they identified as a defixio (curse tablet). A team of scientists from the Institute of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics in Telč, Czech Republic used X-ray tomographic scans and found text inscribed on the inside. This discovery was announced publicly in 2022, and a peer-reviewed article followed in 2023. In it, epigraphers translated the proto-alphabetic inscription, which read:
You are cursed by the god yhw, cursed.
You will die, cursed—cursed, you will surely die.
Cursed you are by yhw—cursed. 3
The lead tablet discovered in wet-sifting of material from Adam Zertal’s excavations on Mt. Ebal. Photo: Scott Stripling
It is also important to check if the chosen date clashes with any local events that may affect the availability of the Pagoda or cause traffic congestion. After the date and time are determined, the couple can start planning the details of the ceremony. Traditional elements of a Pagoda wedding include a red and gold color scheme, as these are considered auspicious in many Asian cultures. Decorations such as lanterns, flowers, and incense can also be added to create a festive atmosphere. The couple should also consider hiring a traditional Asian-styled wedding officiant who is familiar with Pagoda weddings. This person will guide the couple through the traditional ceremony and perform the necessary rituals. It is important to discuss the details of the ceremony with the officiant to ensure that all the traditional elements are included. In addition to the ceremony, couples may also choose to have a reception following the Pagoda wedding. The reception can be held in a separate venue and can include traditional Asian cuisine, music, and dances. It is important to work closely with a wedding planner or caterer who has experience with Asian weddings to ensure that all the cultural elements are properly incorporated. Lastly, it is important to consider the attire for a Pagoda wedding. Brides may choose to wear a traditional Asian-inspired wedding dress, such as a cheongsam or a kimono. Grooms can opt for a traditional Asian suit or attire that complements the bride's outfit. It is also important to discuss attire guidelines with the wedding officiant to ensure that the couple follows any specific cultural norms. In conclusion, planning a Pagoda wedding can be an exciting and unique experience. From choosing the location and date to incorporating traditional elements into the ceremony, there are many details to consider. By working closely with experienced professionals and being mindful of cultural traditions, couples can create a memorable and meaningful Pagoda wedding..
Reviews for "Tips for planning a budget-friendly pagah wedding"
1. Sarah - 1 star - I was really disappointed with "Planning a Pagah Wedding." The book lacked depth and provided very generic information that was not helpful at all. It felt like the author simply copied some basic wedding planning tips from other sources and put them together without any real understanding of Pagah traditions or customs. I was hoping for a comprehensive guide specifically focused on planning a Pagah wedding, but this book fell short. I do not recommend it.
2. Michael - 2 stars - "Planning a Pagah Wedding" did not meet my expectations. While it did touch on some aspects of Pagah traditions, the information provided was limited and basic. The book lacked in-depth explanations and failed to address important logistical considerations specific to planning a Pagah wedding. Additionally, the writing style was quite dry and I found it difficult to stay engaged with the content. Overall, I believe there are better resources available for those looking to plan a Pagah wedding.
3. Emily - 1 star - I was extremely disappointed with "Planning a Pagah Wedding." The book failed to provide any unique insights into planning a Pagah wedding and did not offer any practical tips or advice. It felt more like a superficial overview rather than a comprehensive guide. The lack of depth in the content left me feeling unsatisfied and unprepared for the task of planning a Pagah wedding. I would not recommend this book to anyone seeking genuine guidance and valuable information.
4. John - 2 stars - "Planning a Pagah Wedding" left much to be desired. The book did touch on some key elements of Pagah traditions, but it lacked a cohesive structure and failed to provide a clear roadmap for planning a successful Pagah wedding. The information provided was scattered and fragmented, making it difficult to follow and implement. I wish the book had delved deeper into the cultural significance and meaning behind various Pagah wedding rituals. Overall, it fell short of my expectations and I wouldn't recommend it to others in search of a comprehensive guide.