Pagan symbols can be found in various aspects of everyday life, despite the fact that paganism is often associated with ancient beliefs and practices. These symbols, which hold deep spiritual meanings for pagans, have become ingrained in modern society and are often used without necessarily realizing their origins. One pagan symbol that is commonly used is the pentagram. This five-pointed star is often depicted within a circle and is associated with various meanings, including the elements of earth, air, fire, water, and spirit. The pentagram can be found in jewelry, artwork, and even in architectural designs. While it has been adopted by other religions and belief systems, its roots lie in paganism.

What Is the Halloween Switch Witch and Why Are Parents So Against It?

A new holiday tradition is popping up and sparking debate.

SolStock / Getty Images

First came Elf on the Shelf. Now, there’s the Switch Witch, a new Halloween tradition that involves kids trading in candy for gifts. Just like the Elf, this “fun” ritual creates more work for us parents—when we’re already scrambling to pull off intricate costumes and coordinate trick-or-treating with scores of friends and family. But plenty of Switch Witch critics say we’re also robbing children off a rite of passage: eating way too much Halloween candy.

If you haven’t heard of the Switch Witch, an Instagram video created by user @emilyxlevi explains it pretty well. Basically, a kid goes out trick-or-treating on Halloween. Then, when they get home, they get to pick out five of their favorite pieces of candy. What happens to the rest of their hard-earned bounty? They leave it outside for the Switch Witch, who magically replaces it with a toy the next morning. According to the creator, this tradition keeps little ones from eating too much junk, and makes Halloween all the more exciting!

Thousands of commenters are taking issue with what they see as an eye-rolling idea for many, diverse reasons. Chief among them is that kids have been gorging on Kit-Kats and Starbursts for decades, on this one day a year. So why are we taking this time-honored cultural birthright away from today’s children? And, the prevailing logic seems to be that if you don’t want your tots to get sick on Pixy Stix and Reese’s Peanut Butter candies, then Halloween presents the perfect opportunity to teach them moderation and self-control—not to force them to give their candy away to the anti-Tooth Fairy.

Those who want to burn the Switch Witch at the stake didn’t hold back with their strong condemnation of the “tradition,” with one person simply saying, “This sucks.” Someone else groaned, “Just let the kid have fun once a year,” while another person echoed, “What happened to parents just letting kids be kids and enjoy Halloween?” One angry commenter blasted the creator, accusing them of “literally cheating your kid out of a childhood.” And yet another unimpressed observer said, “Glad you were not my dad.”

Dozens upon dozens of commenters weighed in calling the Switch Witch the Grinch of October 31. And speaking of which, Christmas is right around the corner, and we parents are already stretched thin budget-wise. So why are we shelling out money for toys now—especially if you’re like me, and have multiple children? “Way to waste people's money on the candy they bought for your kids,” noted someone else in the vein of cent squandering.

Beyond just taking away your money and your kids' joy, one commenter shared a very personal reason why the Switch Witch may even lead to problems regulating oneself later in life: “My parents did this and it was so detrimental to my relationship with food. Everything was monitored and restricted so when I had a chance to have some ‘unhealthy’ food when they weren’t around, I went wild with it.”

The commenter went on to warn, “Don’t do this to your kids. Teach them that the candy will always be there so they don’t have to eat it all at once. Build a good relationship with food rather than restricting the ‘bad’ food.”

To be fair, there were a lot of parents who liked the idea of the Switch Witch as well. (Are these the same people who embrace Elf on the Shelf with a passion—and create Instagrams devoted to showing off the elf’s obnoxious daily feats?) One person writes that they have a toddler who doesn't need the candy, but they want him to experience trick-or-treating, calling it a "cute tradition to start."

Other fans of the toy trade-in tradition wondered why this concept enrages people who aren’t affected by what some parents choose to do for their own families. Fair enough. No need for full-on parent shaming.

That said, the Switch Witch is not welcome to park her broom anywhere near my house. Ditto to the Elf on the Shelf, who can keep his striped tights and mocking grin as far from our Christmas tree as possible. Because this mama doesn’t have enough time (or the budget) to go out and buy a bunch of gifts just shy of the biggest splurge season of the year.

Besides, in the end, dressing up and asking neighbors for candy seems like one of the only traditions left that is still simple, pure, and just like it was when we were kids. Can’t we just leave it this way?

Family spark debate after sharing their controversial Halloween candy tradition

A family in Utah divided social media users by explaining a tradition they have they call the ‘switch witch’.

Sharing a video of how the tradition works the family explained their daughter would go trick-or-treating for Halloween candy like millions of other kids with one twist.

Rather than keeping all the candy, she is allowed to keep five pieces and puts the rest in a small plastic basket that is then placed on their front door porch. The next morning the sweets are replaced with a toy for their daughter to keep.

Instagram page Emilyxlevi, shared an explanatory video of the tradition on October 5 and the post has so far been liked more than 682,000 times.

“The switch witch is back! This has been such a fun tradition!,” the page wrote as a caption.

“Better yet, it’s been a way to let our daughter enjoy every bit of Halloween without eating tons of candy. You can get fun with it and give your witch a name! The witch who stops by our house is Wilda.”

The family in Utah divided social media users by explaining a tradition they have they call the ‘switch witch’. Credit: Instagram/@emilyxlevi

Despite the well-meaning intentions to cut back on their daughter's candy intake, some social media users were less impressed with the tradition.

“It’s one day of the year. Give it a rest. You think it’s better to buy your kid toys than to let them have the bite sized candy?” one Instagram user wrote.

“Why not just teach moderation? Like it’s a great idea but it’s not really teaching her anything,” another added.

“Yes, the kids do not necessarily need the candy but the option to teach moderation is right there and instead you’re advocating a tooth fairy thing based on candy gotten from other people,” a user commented.

Some social media users were less impressed with the tradition and voiced their concerns. Credit: Instagram/@emilyxlevi

Despite the criticism, some Instagram users were delighted with the tradition and indicated they may adopt it themselves for the upcoming festive season.

“My 2 y.o has special medical needs and doesn’t want to/isn’t able to eat much by mouth,” a social media user noted.

“This looks like a great way to still have him participate in the trick or treating and get something he wants in the end. All these negative comments are crazy. don’t follow his advice if you don’t want to.”

Regardless of the heated debate raging in the comments section, some users joked that the parents just wanted to sneakily munch on their daughter’s candy themselves.

The Switch Witch or Moderation? Tips to Save Your Kids From Halloween Candy Madness

Should children be allowed to eat their candy stash or is introducing them to the ‘Switch Witch’ a better move? We explore both options in this post.

When Halloween night arrives, the excitement in the air is palpable. Kids, young and old, eagerly put on their costumes, ready to embark on the timeless tradition of trick-or-treating. But once the bags and buckets are filled to the brim with Halloween candy, parents often find themselves asking, “What do we do with all this candy?!”

There are a few different approaches for parents to manage the sugar rush (and inevitable crash) that comes along with Halloween Candy.

Let’s talk about the Switch Witch and creating healthy boundaries with candy (without demonizing the delicacies and creating a food complex). Both provide great solutions for keeping the magic alive while maintaining a balanced approach to all those treats.

While it has been adopted by other religions and belief systems, its roots lie in paganism. Another pagan symbol that has found its way into everyday life is the triquetra. This symbol, often resembling a three-pointed knot, has been associated with Celtic paganism and represents the concept of three-in-one or the interconnectedness of mind, body, and spirit.

What’s a 'Switch Witch'?

The Switch Witch is a make-believe character who loves Halloween just as much as kids do. This magical witch comes out to play on Halloween night (or later that week). She visits your home to check out all the candy spoils from your child’s night of trick-or-treating.

The idea is simple: rather than consume all of the sweets, kids leave some of their Halloween candy out as a gift for the Switch Witch, and in return, the witch “switches” their candy for a non-food treat—like a small toy or book— to show her appreciation.

It can be seen in jewelry, tattoos, and even in branding for various products and businesses. Additionally, the Wheel of the Year, a pagan symbol depicting the eight Sabbats or seasonal celebrations, is often used in modern pagan practices and can be seen in calendars, holiday decorations, and even in the names of festivals or events. This symbol serves as a reminder of the cyclical nature of life and the changing seasons. Despite the increasing secularization of society, pagan symbols continue to hold significance for many individuals. They serve as a connection to ancient beliefs and a way to honor the natural world. While some may adopt these symbols for fashion purposes or as a trendy aesthetic, there are still those who hold them in deep spiritual regard. Overall, pagan symbols have made their way into everyday life, whether it be through fashion, art, or cultural traditions. These symbols act as a reminder of our connection to nature and our collective human history. Regardless of personal beliefs, they continue to hold meaning for many and are likely to remain a part of our society for years to come..

Reviews for "The Pagan Origins of Traditional Holidays and Celebrations"

1. Jane Smith - 2 out of 5 stars - I was really disappointed with "Pagan Symbols in Everyday Life". I expected a thoughtful exploration of pagan symbols and their significance in modern society, but instead, I found a superficial and poorly researched book. The author failed to provide any real depth or historical context to the symbols discussed, often reducing them to generic "witchy" imagery. The lack of scholarly references and reliance on anecdotal evidence also made the book feel more like a personal opinion piece rather than an academic exploration. Overall, I found this book to be a missed opportunity and not a credible source for anyone interested in studying pagan symbols.

2. John Thompson - 1 out of 5 stars - I regret buying "Pagan Symbols in Everyday Life". It was nothing more than a shallow attempt to cash in on the popularity of pagan themes. The author's understanding of pagan symbols was severely lacking, and it was clear that they had done minimal research. The book felt like a collection of random thoughts hastily put together, without any coherence or structure. The discussions on symbolism were vague and lacked substance. I would not recommend this book to anyone seeking a meaningful exploration of pagan symbols and their relevance in modern times.

3. Samantha Johnson - 2 out of 5 stars - "Pagan Symbols in Everyday Life" fell far short of my expectations. The book promised an insightful analysis of pagan symbols, but it failed to deliver. The author seemed to focus more on aesthetic appeal rather than delving into the deeper meanings and cultural significance behind these symbols. The lack of depth and critical analysis made it difficult to gain any real knowledge or understanding from the book. Furthermore, the writing style was overly flowery and lacked clarity, making it a struggle to stay engaged. In short, I found this book to be more of a surface-level exploration rather than the in-depth study I was hoping for.

4. Michael Roberts - 2 out of 5 stars - I found "Pagan Symbols in Everyday Life" to be a disappointment. The book lacked a clear structure and organization, causing the content to feel scattered and disjointed. The author's interpretations of pagan symbols often seemed subjective and unsubstantiated by research or historical references. I was hoping for a more scholarly approach that would provide a deeper understanding of the symbols discussed, but this book fell short. While it may serve as a starting point for those curious about pagan symbols, it is not a comprehensive or reliable resource.

5. Rachel Thompson - 1 out of 5 stars - "Pagan Symbols in Everyday Life" was a waste of my time and money. The author's lack of depth and understanding of the subject matter was glaringly evident throughout the book. It felt more like a quick cash-grab rather than a sincere attempt to explore the significance of pagan symbols in our daily lives. The writing style was also highly repetitive, with the author constantly rehashing the same ideas without adding any new insights. Overall, the book lacked substance and failed to provide any valuable information or perspectives on the topic. I would not recommend it to anyone interested in learning about pagan symbols.

The Pagan Symbolism Behind Popular Tattoos in Contemporary Culture