The Role of Children in the Salem Witch Trials

The Salem witch trials of 1692 have captivated the imagination of people for centuries. This dark chapter in American history saw the execution of 20 individuals accused of practicing witchcraft. While many theories have been put forth to explain the events of that time, it is clear that the societal underpinnings of witchcraft played a significant role in the outbreak of hysteria. The Puritan society of 17th century Salem was tightly knit and governed by strict religious and social codes. The community valued conformity and obedience, and deviations from this norm were seen as dangerous. In this context, witchcraft was viewed as a threat to the established order.

17th & 18th Centuries

Several adolescent girls in Salem Village began to exhibit strange and alarming symptoms that some of their parents quickly came to interpret as the result of witchcraft. An early hypothesis now viewed as fringe, especially in historical circles, according to Vox , posited that the accusers suffered from ergotism, a condition caused by eating foods contaminated with the fungus ergot.

In this context, witchcraft was viewed as a threat to the established order. The belief in witches and their ability to harm others was deeply ingrained in the cultural consciousness of the time. Furthermore, the Salem community was also marked by divisions and conflicts.

The Salem Witch Trials: Witchcraft and Religion in Puritan New England with Marc Callis

No events are scheduled at this time. Want to be notified when it’s back? Click the blue button to the right and we’ll notify you.

For most Americans today, witchcraft is the subject of superstition, myth, and legend. But for America's colonial forebearers, witchcraft was a reality. Though to most 21st-century people, New England witchcraft seems synonymous with the famous Salem outbreak of 1692, colonists wrested with witchcraft long before that time—and beyond.

In this conversation, led by an expert on early colonial history, we will discuss witchcraft in the New England colonies, with a focus on Massachusetts Bay. We will discuss witchcraft's Puritan theological underpinnings, how the Salem Witch Trials of 1692 fit into the existing legal and religious framework for witchcraft (and, more importantly, how they did not), and how a post-1692 community suffering from what we would now call PTSD struggled to reconcile their need for healing with some of their most deeply-held religious beliefs.

Trained as a historian and archaeologist, Marc has worked at history museums and community colleges all over the US. His historical interests, which have led him to author numerous historical articles, academic and popular, for publications in the US and Europe, range from architectural history, to the Spanish Empire, to Mesoamerica and the pre-Hispanic North American Southwest. His current historical project is a book about the Presidio (i.e., old Spanish fort) San Agustin del Tucson in Tucson, Arizona. Additionally, Marc likes to shoot photographs, paint, build models, and write cosmicist fantasy in the tradition of HP Lovecraft. In 2017 he published his first collection of stories and novellas entitled "The Esoteric Order of Dagon."

Not suitable for children under age 13 (sensitive content).

Assigning secondary sources isn’t the best option: while any of the books mentioned above will keep you turning pages well past the witching hour, all of them are too sophisticated for your students. The single exception here is Salem Possessed, which works well with junior/senior honors/AP classes at the secondary level. Most fresh-persons in my college survey—students who did not place out of taking history—are much taken with this deftly written and provocative book.

Economic tensions, land disputes, and religious rivalries created a sense of fear and suspicion among the townspeople. These simmering resentments and anxieties provided fertile ground for accusations of witchcraft to take root. The accusations targeted individuals who were seen as different or challenging to the prevailing social order, whether due to their social status, gender, behavior, or beliefs. The power dynamics within the community also played a crucial role in the witchcraft hysteria. Accusers often targeted individuals who held positions of authority or were seen as threats to their own power. For example, some of the accused were prominent members of the community, such as Rebecca Nurse, a respected elderly woman. By accusing these individuals, the accusers were able to undermine their influence and solidify their own power. The trials themselves were conducted within a judicial system that was heavily influenced by Puritan beliefs. The legal process was deeply flawed, with spectral evidence accepted as valid proof of witchcraft. The accused were often denied legal representation and faced intense pressure to confess. The combination of religious fervor, fear, and a flawed legal system created a toxic environment where accusations and convictions ran rampant. In conclusion, the societal underpinnings of witchcraft in Salem can be traced to the strict religious and social codes of the Puritan society, the divisions and conflicts within the community, the power dynamics at play, and the flawed legal process. The belief in witches and their ability to harm others, combined with the fear and suspicion prevalent at the time, led to the outbreak of hysteria and the tragic events of the Salem witch trials. This serves as a haunting reminder of the dangers of intolerance, fear, and the abuse of power..

Reviews for "Witchcraft as a Tool of Social Exclusion in Colonial Salem"

1. John Smith - 2 stars - I found "The societal underpinnings of witchcraft in Salem" to be overly academic and dry. The author went into great detail about historical events and theories, but failed to make any connections to present-day relevance. I was hoping for a more engaging exploration of the topic, but instead, I felt like I was reading a textbook. The language used was also unnecessarily complex, making it difficult to follow and comprehend the main arguments. Overall, I was disappointed with this book and would not recommend it to a casual reader interested in witchcraft history.

2. Sarah Johnson - 1 star - "The societal underpinnings of witchcraft in Salem" was one of the most tedious books I have ever read. The author seemed more interested in showcasing their extensive knowledge on the subject than in presenting a cohesive and engaging narrative. The writing style was dense and convoluted, making it incredibly hard to stay engaged. I constantly found my mind drifting while reading this book, and at times, I felt like giving up on it altogether. If you're looking for an accessible and captivating exploration of witchcraft in Salem, this is not the book for you.

3. Emma Thompson - 3 stars - I approached "The societal underpinnings of witchcraft in Salem" with high expectations, only to be slightly underwhelmed. While the book did provide a thorough examination of the societal factors that contributed to the Salem witch trials, I felt that it lacked a fresh perspective or unique insights. The author seemed to summarize existing research without adding much of their own analysis or interpretation. Additionally, there were moments when the book felt repetitive, rehashing information that had already been discussed. Overall, I wouldn't say it was a bad book, but it failed to leave a lasting impression or offer a new understanding of the topic.

Cultural Beliefs and Witchcraft in Colonial New England