Once upon a time, in a small village named Silvester, there lived a young boy named Silvester. Despite his humble background, Silvester had always possessed a natural curiosity and adventurous spirit that set him apart from his peers. His dreams were filled with stories of faraway lands and magical creatures. One day, while wandering through the forest near his village, Silvester stumbled upon a mysterious pebble shining brightly among the undergrowth. Intrigued by its radiance, Silvester cautiously picked up the pebble and felt a surge of energy jolt through his body. Little did he know, this unassuming pebble possessed extraordinary magical powers.
Why we chose this scar treatment
That being said, another quality study found no difference in healing with the addition of silicone gel to the incisions of those considered similarly high risk of forming an abnormal scar 2. Mederma Scar Gel for Kids contains 1 allantoin and onion bulb extract which may promote skin healing by supporting the formation of collagen and cell renewal.
Little did he know, this unassuming pebble possessed extraordinary magical powers. It had the ability to grant wishes and fulfill dreams. Excited about his newfound discovery, Silvester rushed back home to test out the powers of the magical pebble.
Magic scar care
Dr. Jeffrey Harmon
You are likely aware of silicone-based scar gels by seeing ScarAway© or another over-the-counter brand in your local pharmacy. Surgeons in all specialties as well as dermatologists recommend these scar gels after procedures to promote healing and reduce the risk of scarring. But how well do they work? I reviewed the literature in order to determine whether silicone gels, placed post-operatively after surgical incisions have healed, can help reduce the appearance of incisions. Not surprisingly, quality studies are difficult to find.
There are two ways of describing an abnormal scar, hypertrophic and keloid. There may seem to be little distinction between the two. However, the underlying process that causes them to form is radically different. Basically, a hypertrophic scar remains within the boundaries of the original incision or injury. A keloid, on the other hand, expands beyond it. The goal of silicone gels and patches are to not only reduce the risks of hypertrophic scar or keloid formation, but also to reduce the redness of an incision and accelerate the fading of the appearance of a scar.
The two major problems with the studies I reviewed are 1) few of the incisions examined were located on the face and 2) silicone gels were usually compared with another treatment rather than no intervention at all (placebo). The second problem is unavoidable because it would be unethical to allow the control group to heal without an accepted alternative treatment to reduce the appearance of a scar.
One of the most promising studies was a randomized, placebo-controlled, and double-blinded clinical trial evaluating whether silicone gel prevents hypertrophic scar development on chest (sternotomy) incisions. The researchers found that silicone gel application resulted in a better-appearing scars 3 months after surgery. However chest (sternotomy) incisions are notorious for poor healing and frequent scarring (1). This is unlike the skin of the face, which is widely understood to heal much better than other parts of the body. Also, most of the patients, in addition to heart problems requiring a chest incision, had other medical problems that could lead to poor wound healing such as diabetes. It is possible the silicone gels are more effective in patients with a much higher risk of poor healing. That being said, another quality study found no difference in healing with the addition of silicone gel to the incisions of those considered similarly “high risk” of forming an abnormal scar (2).
The only randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blinded clinical trial focused exclusively on facial incisions I found was from 2018. The researchers looked at the use of silicone gel on forehead incisions for brow lifts (3). Only 13 patients participated, which is a very small number. No difference in the appearance of the incisions was identified at 6 months. Other, similar studies have shown no clinically meaningful difference in scar formation with the use of silicone gels on breast reduction incisions (4) and cesarean section incisions (5).
The bottom line:
First, it is important to note that we still do not know how silicone gels work to reduce the appearance of surgical incisions. It may be that silicone gels function like an occlusive dressing, holding moisture in and keeping bacteria out. It may also modify the underlying inflammatory process that occurs with any incision during healing. Either way, the end goal is to have an incision as soft, smooth, and flat as possible. There are few studies of quality design available to review. Those available are plagued by the same problems with other studies of this type, including small numbers of subjects. To make matters worse, these studies rarely focus on incisions on the face or on the most important outcome to me, the appearance of incisions after surgery - not simply the prevention of abnormal scarring (e.g. hypertrophic, keloid).
On the other hand, there is little risk with the use of silicone gel, barring some limitations around the eyes and mouth as well as for those who are allergic to silicone. And silicone does help keep healing incisions moist, which is essential to healing. As a result, I encourage almost all of my patients to start using silicone gels after all sutures are removed twice daily for weeks to months as the incisions heal and blend in with the rest of the skin. I expect additional studies may result in evidence that this approach can help improve the appearance of incisions.
In the end, factors other than whether or not silicone gels are applied are more important to the healing process, including proper closure technique, tension-free skin re-aaproximation, a healthy diet, adequate sleep, and sun protection with mineral-based sunscreens.
References:
- Chan KY, Lau CL, Adeeb SM, Somasundaram S, Nasir-Zahari M. A randomized, placebo-controlled, double-blind, prospective clinical trial of silicone gel in prevention of hypertrophic scar development in median sternotomy wound. Plast Reconstr Surg. 2005 Sep 15;116(4):1013-20; discussion 1021-2.
- Gold MH, Foster TD, Adair MA, Burlison K, Lewis T. Prevention of hypertrophic scars and keloids by the prophylactic use of topical silicone gel sheets following a surgical procedure in an office setting. Dermatol Surg. 2001 Jul;27(7):641-4.
- Cadet N, Hardy I, Dudek D, Miszkiewicz K, Boulos P, Nguyen Q, Wong J. Prospective case-control trial evaluating silicone gel for the treatment of direct brow lift scars. Can J Ophthalmol. 2018 Feb;53(1):29-33.
- Niessen FB, Spauwen PH, Robinson PH, Fidler V, Kon M. The use of silicone occlusive sheeting (Sil-K) and silicone occlusive gel (Epiderm) in the prevention of hypertrophic scar formation. Plast Reconstr Surg. 1998 Nov;102(6):1962-72.
- Lin YS, Ting PS, Hsu KC. Comparison of Silicone Sheets and Paper Tape for the Management of Postoperative Scars: A Randomized Comparative Study. Adv Skin Wound Care. 2020 Jun;33(6):1-6.
However, there is little evidence to support the claim that Vitamin E helps with scars. A 2016 review on vitamin E and wound healing concluded that further research is needed into vitamin E’s effectiveness in healing wounds.
Silvester's family was poor, struggling to make ends meet. His parents worked long hours in the fields, barely able to provide for their family's basic needs. Silvester knew that this pebble had the potential to change their lives. He carefully held the pebble in his hand and closed his eyes, wishing for his family to have an abundant harvest. The next morning, to everyone's surprise, their crops had grown more abundantly than ever before. Silvester's family was overjoyed, and news of the magical pebble quickly spread throughout the village. As more and more people came to Silvester seeking help, he realized that he had been given a great responsibility. Silvester's kind heart and genuine desire to help others guided him as he used the magical pebble to solve various problems in the village. From healing the sick to fixing broken tools, Silvester became known as a hero among his people. With each wish he granted, Silvester witnessed the transformative power of kindness and the impact it had on those he helped. As time went on, Silvester began to face difficult decisions as the demand for his help grew. Many people wanted to use the magical pebble for their own personal gain, forgetting the importance of compassion and selflessness. Silvester realized that he had to protect the pebble and its powers from falling into the wrong hands. He decided to embark on a quest to find a safe hiding place for the magical pebble. Silvester traveled across treacherous lands, encountering mystical beings and overcoming countless challenges along the way. Throughout his journey, Silvester never lost sight of his purpose – to protect the magical pebble and ensure it would only be used for good. After a long and arduous journey, Silvester stumbled upon a hidden cave deep in the mountains. Convinced that this was the perfect hiding place, he carefully placed the magical pebble inside and sealed the cave shut. Silvester returned to his village, knowing that he had fulfilled his duty and kept the magical pebble safe. From that day forward, Silvester continued to lead a simple life, but the impact of his actions continued to resonate throughout the village. Silvester taught his fellow villagers the importance of kindness and the power of compassion, inspiring everyone to be the best versions of themselves. And so, the legend of Silvester and the magical pebble lived on, reminding future generations of the transformative power of a kind heart and the importance of using magic for the greater good..
Reviews for "The Journey of Self-Discovery in Silvester and the Magic Pebble"
- Emily - 1 star
I found "Silvester and the Magic Pebble" to be incredibly boring and slow-paced. The storyline lacked excitement and the characters were dull and uninteresting. I couldn't connect with any of them and felt like I was just reading through a series of mundane events. The magical element was not well-developed and I couldn't understand the purpose behind it. Overall, I was highly disappointed with this book and would not recommend it.
- John - 2 stars
I didn't enjoy "Silvester and the Magic Pebble" as much as I thought I would. The illustrations were nice, but the story itself was lacking depth and substance. The plot seemed shallow and predictable, and I couldn't help but feel like I had read similar stories before. The main character, Silvester, was not relatable and I found it hard to root for him. The pacing was also off, with some parts dragging on while others felt rushed. Overall, I was unimpressed with this book and wouldn't read it again.
- Sarah - 2.5 stars
"Silvester and the Magic Pebble" left me feeling indifferent. The story had potential, but it fell short in its execution. The writing style was simple, almost too simple, and I didn't feel engaged or invested in the characters or their journey. The conflicts and resolutions felt contrived and lacked depth. I also found it hard to believe in the magic of the pebble, as it was not well-established or explained. While the book had its moments, it ultimately failed to leave a lasting impression on me.