Carnival Magic's Onboard Activities: A Cruise Critic Rating Breakdown

The Carnival Magic is a popular cruise ship that offers a range of amenities and entertainment options for passengers. It has received mixed reviews from cruise critics, with some praising its onboard activities and dining options, while others have raised concerns about its crowded public spaces and lack of quiet areas. One of the main highlights of the Carnival Magic is its extensive array of onboard activities. Passengers can enjoy water slides, a ropes course, mini golf, and even a bowling alley. These options provide plenty of entertainment for families and groups of friends. The ship also offers a variety of dining options, from casual buffet-style eateries to more formal sit-down restaurants.

OS stands for "Ocean Suite" and category SS is "Spa Suite", recently changed to Junior Suite. These cabins have: twin beds that convert to king, sitting area with armchair and coffee table, sofa, dressing area with vanity, large balcony, wall safe, 2 big closets, mini-bar, refrigerator, private whirlpool bath with tub and shower, television and phone, balcony lounge chair, patio chair and table, pillow menu, bathrobes, hairdryer.

First of all-balcony, and again twin beds that convert to king, sofa, private bath with shower, safe, closet, mini bar, television and phone, sitting area with chair and coffee table, bathrobes and hairdryer. Grand Suites have also a double sofa bed and large private balcony, sitting area with 2-armchairs and a coffee table, desk, dressing area with vanity, walk-in closet, safe box, TV, phone, refrigerator, mini-bar, private bath with whirlpool tub and shower, patio chair and table, balcony lounge chair, pillow menu, bathrobes, hairdryer.

The ship also offers a variety of dining options, from casual buffet-style eateries to more formal sit-down restaurants. Many reviewers have praised the quality and variety of the food available on board. Despite these positive aspects, some cruise critics have raised concerns about the crowded nature of the Carnival Magic.

8 cabin locations on cruise ships you should definitely avoid

As Cruise Team Lead, Gene Sloan oversees cruise content at TPG and also writes many of TPG's main cruise guides. He has spent nearly 30 years writing about cruise ships and cruising, and he is one of the world's best-known authorities on the topic.

This post contains references to products from one or more of our advertisers. We may receive compensation when you click on links to those products. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. For an explanation of our Advertising Policy, visit this page.

I still can remember the worst cruise ship cabin I ever had.

It was on a Carnival Cruise Line ship — I can't remember which one — and it was right in the middle of what I have come to call the "Bermuda Triangle of Bad Cabins" on Carnival ships.

This is the area on those ships around the aft elevator bank on the cabin deck that sits just above the main entertainment deck. If you're in a cabin in this area, particularly one on the starboard side, you are dealing with not only the noise of the Carnival rowdies emerging from the elevators late into the night but also — on many vessels — the sounds of the piano bar and nightclub emanating up the stairway from right below you.

It isn't much better in the cabins around the forward elevator bank and stairway on the same deck, which on many Carnival ships are right above the bustling central atrium and adjacent casino. That's not exactly a quiet area.

Is it obvious I go to bed early?

Picking the perfect cabin location on a cruise ship can be a subjective exercise. Some people want to be on a high deck for the views. Others want to be on a low deck for stability. Some want to be near the kids clubs or the spa or some other venue they know they'll visit often. Some really couldn't care less. Instead, they'll book "guarantee" cabins, which is where you tell the cruise line to just pick any old cabin for you, as long as you get a deal.

Still, after testing hundreds of cabins and cabin types over the years on more than 160 ships, I've determined a few hard-and-fast rules about cabins you should usually avoid.

For more cruise guides, news and tips, sign up for TPG's cruise newsletter.

With a capacity of over 3,600 passengers, the ship can sometimes feel overcrowded, especially during peak travel seasons. Some reviewers have also noted a lack of quiet areas on board, making it difficult for passengers seeking a more relaxing experience. However, it's important to note that different passengers have different expectations and preferences when it comes to cruising. While some may find the Carnival Magic to be too crowded, others may enjoy the lively atmosphere and variety of activities. Ultimately, it's up to each individual traveler to decide if the Carnival Magic is the right cruise ship for them..

Reviews for "Carnival Magic vs. Other Cruise Ships: A Cruise Critic Comparison"

1. Amy Walker - 1 star

I was extremely disappointed with my experience on the Carnival Magic. The ship was crowded and hectic, making it difficult to enjoy any of the amenities or activities. The staff seemed overwhelmed and unorganized, leading to long wait times for meals and excursions. The food in the main dining room was mediocre at best, with limited options for those with dietary restrictions. Overall, I would not recommend the Carnival Magic to anyone looking for a relaxing and enjoyable cruise experience.

2. David Thompson - 2 stars

I had high expectations for the Carnival Magic, but unfortunately, it fell short. The ship felt outdated and in need of a renovation. The cabins were small and lacked basic amenities. The entertainment options were lackluster, with repetitive shows and limited activities for adults. The onboard dining options were mediocre at best, and I found myself longing for more variety and quality. I wouldn't rush to book another cruise on the Carnival Magic.

3. Michelle Robinson - 1 star

My experience on the Carnival Magic was a complete disaster. The ship was overcrowded, and I felt like I was constantly surrounded by noisy and inconsiderate passengers. The staff, although friendly, seemed overwhelmed and unable to handle the demands of such a large group of people. The food was mediocre, and I often found myself waiting in long lines for subpar meals. The excursions were rushed and poorly organized, leaving little time to truly enjoy the destinations. I would not recommend the Carnival Magic to anyone seeking a relaxing and enjoyable cruise vacation.

4. Steven Harris - 2 stars

The Carnival Magic left much to be desired. The ship was constantly crowded, and there were long wait times for everything, from meals to activities. The staff seemed disengaged and uninterested in providing quality service. The dining options were repetitive and lacking in variety. The onboard entertainment was subpar and didn't offer much in terms of excitement or engagement. Overall, I wouldn't consider the Carnival Magic as a top choice for a memorable cruise experience.

The Carnival Magic Experience: A Cruise Critic's Rating and Review