Save money on cleaning supplies with these magic eraser substitutes

By admin

Magic Eraser is a popular cleaning tool developed by the company Mr. Clean, known for its ability to effectively remove tough stains and marks without the need for harsh chemicals. Although it is highly regarded for its cleaning capabilities, the original Magic Eraser can be quite expensive compared to other cleaning products on the market. However, there are cheaper alternatives available that provide similar results at a fraction of the cost. One cost-effective alternative to the Magic Eraser is using a regular kitchen sponge. While it may not have the same specialized materials as the Magic Eraser, a sponge with a slightly abrasive surface can still effectively remove stains and marks from various surfaces.


I have found the the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers work wonders for removing residue from items I engrave in the laser. The problem is they don't last long. The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on. Can anyone suggest another solution?

The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on. The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on.

Cheaper version of magic eraser

While it may not have the same specialized materials as the Magic Eraser, a sponge with a slightly abrasive surface can still effectively remove stains and marks from various surfaces. Additionally, it can be used with household cleaning products to achieve even better results. Another affordable option is a melamine foam cleaning sponge, sometimes referred to as a generic or no-name version of the Magic Eraser.

Cheaper version of magic eraser

I have found the the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers work wonders for removing residue from items I engrave in the laser. The problem is they don't last long. The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on. Can anyone suggest another solution?

Steve Clarkson 10-11-2012, 4:08 PM What material are you engraving? Joe Hillmann 10-11-2012, 4:13 PM Powdercoated aluminum at the moment but I also use it quite a bit on rowmark as well. Chris DeGerolamo 10-11-2012, 4:16 PM have you tried a [pencil] eraser? or DNA? I also like simple green. Duncan Crawford 10-11-2012, 4:23 PM

I have found the the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers work wonders for removing residue from items I engrave in the laser. The problem is they don't last long. The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on. Can anyone suggest another solution?

At one point the Epilog tech tips suggested the smooth Fast Orange for residue removal. Works for me on wood.

Wes Mitchell 10-11-2012, 4:23 PM

You can try IPI's LazrClean, it works pretty well on just about anything. Just spray it on and let it sit for a minute. You could still use the magic eraser, but probably wouldn't go through as many.

Tucker Alford 10-12-2012, 9:16 AM

I use mineral spirits on just about everything. We cut down old shirts into small pieces, douse with Mineral Spirits in a small squirt bottle & wipe. Throw the rag out after a few cleanings. Cheap & works on everything.

Martin Boekers 10-12-2012, 11:00 AM

These usually last me quite a while, I try not to "bear" down when using them.
I also found the generic ones don't work as well. I would like to find them wholesale somewhere.

I have found the the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers work wonders for removing residue from items I engrave in the laser. The problem is they don't last long. The project I am working on right now probably uses up ten of them per day, so it starts to add up, but so far it is the only thing that effectively takes off the residue without damaging the part I engraved on. Can anyone suggest another solution?
Cheaper version of magic eraser

These sponges are typically made from melamine resin, which has a similar texture and cleaning power as the original Magic Eraser. They are often sold in bulk or multipacks, making them an economical choice for individuals looking for a cheaper alternative. Furthermore, DIY solutions can be used as a cheaper version of the Magic Eraser. One such solution involves creating a paste using baking soda and water. This paste can be applied to a sponge or cloth and used to scrub away stains and marks. Baking soda is known for its gentle abrasiveness and ability to lift dirt and grime, making it an effective and inexpensive cleaning solution. Overall, while the Magic Eraser is a highly effective cleaning tool, there are cheaper alternatives available for individuals on a budget. Regular sponges, melamine foam cleaning sponges, and DIY solutions using baking soda can all provide similar cleaning results without breaking the bank. It is important to note, however, that the effectiveness of these alternatives may vary depending on the specific cleaning task and the surface being cleaned..

Reviews for "The frugal way to clean: cheaper substitutes for the magic eraser"

1. Samantha - 2 stars - I was really excited to try this cheaper version of the magic eraser, but unfortunately, it just didn't live up to my expectations. The eraser was not as durable as the original one and broke apart easily. Additionally, it didn't remove tough stains or marks as effectively. I ended up having to scrub harder and longer to get the same results. Overall, I was disappointed and would rather spend a little extra money to get the original magic eraser.
2. John - 1 star - I bought this cheaper alternative to the magic eraser thinking it would be a great money-saving option. However, I was highly disappointed with its performance. The eraser was smaller in size and didn't hold up well against tough stains. It fell apart easily and didn't have the same cleaning power. I would not recommend this cheaper version as it is not worth the savings if it doesn't get the job done effectively.
3. Sarah - 2 stars - I decided to give this cheaper magic eraser a try, but unfortunately, it did not compare to the original. The eraser didn't last as long and tore apart easily. It also didn't remove stains and marks as effectively, requiring more effort and time to clean. I would rather spend a little more on the original magic eraser for better results and longevity. The cheaper version simply did not meet my expectations.

Finding a cheaper magic eraser alternative that won't compromise quality

Cost-saving alternatives to the popular magic eraser