The Andover witchcraft trials were a series of trials that took place in Andover, Massachusetts in 1692 during the infamous Salem witch trials. While the Salem trials are more well-known, the Andover trials were also significant in their own right. These trials were part of the wider hysteria that swept through the Massachusetts Bay Colony, resulting in the execution of 20 people. The hysteria began in 1692 when several young girls in Salem Village began experiencing fits and making accusations of witchcraft. The panic quickly spread, and accusations were made against numerous individuals in the area. The Andover trials occurred after the neighboring town of Salem, as the accusations and fear continued to escalate.
The vivid and painful legacy of the Salem witch trials has endured for centuries as a horrific example of false witness. Noted playwright Arthur Miller dramatized the events of 1692 in his 1953 Tony Award-winning play “The Crucible,” using the trials as an allegory for the anti-Communist “witch hunts” led by Sen. Joseph McCarthy in the 1950s. Miller himself was caught up in McCarthy’s net, likely because of his play.
Cotton Mather, a Puritan minister and author at the center of the witch trials, was an observer at the hanging, and in his diary he noted Carrier as a rampant hag and possible Queen of Hell. Martha Allen Carrier was the only one of Faith Ingalls children to be executed, but she was not the only one accused, examined, imprisoned, and tried.
The Andover trials occurred after the neighboring town of Salem, as the accusations and fear continued to escalate. The trials in Andover were not as well-documented as those in Salem, but they followed a similar pattern. Accusations were made against both men and women, young and old.
24 and More
The best source is the Salem Witch Trials: Documentary Archive and Transcription Project
“ SWP No. 024: Martha Carrier Executed, August 19, 1692 .” SWP No. 094: SWP No. 024: Martha Carrier Executed, August 19, 1692 – New Salem – Pelican, University of Virginia, 2018, salem.lib.virginia.edu/n24.html.
The accused were often put on trial based on spectral evidence, which involved claims that the accused person's spirit had taken on the form of an animal or a ghost to harm the accuser. The Andover trials resulted in the conviction and execution of five individuals. However, unlike in Salem, the trials in Andover quickly lost momentum. Many of the accused were found not guilty, and the fervor of the witch trials began to wane. This was in part due to the efforts of Reverend Thomas Barnard, the minister of the Andover church, who advocated for caution and moderation in the proceedings. The Andover witchcraft trials were a dark chapter in American history. They were characterized by fear, paranoia, and the destruction of innocent lives. The trials served as a reminder of the dangers of hysteria and the power of mass belief. In the years following the trials, the Massachusetts legislature passed a law to compensate the families of those who had been wrongly convicted and executed. This was a small step towards acknowledging the injustice that took place during the witch trials. Today, the Andover witchcraft trials are remembered as a tragic event that showed the dangers of mass hysteria and the importance of skepticism and critical thinking. They serve as a reminder of the need to protect the rights and liberties of all individuals, even in times of fear and uncertainty..
Reviews for "Andover's Accused: Uncovering the Lives of the Alleged Witches"
- Emily - 2 stars - The Andover witchcraft trials were an absolute mess. The evidence presented was weak and unreliable, and it seemed like the whole thing was just a witch hunt. The accused were not given a fair chance to defend themselves, and it was clear that the outcome was predetermined. The whole trial lacked any sense of justice, and it was a dark stain on our history.
- David - 1 star - The Andover witchcraft trials were a complete disgrace. The judges and jurors were biased and seemed to have their minds made up before the trial even began. Innocent people were accused and convicted based on superstitious beliefs and hearsay. It was a clear abuse of power and a violation of basic human rights. These trials should serve as a reminder of how fear and ignorance can lead to devastating consequences.
- Sarah - 2 stars - I found the Andover witchcraft trials to be deeply unsettling. It was disturbing to see how easily people were willing to believe in and accuse others of witchcraft without any solid evidence. The whole process lacked transparency and fairness, with the accused being subjected to harsh interrogations and not given proper opportunities to defend themselves. It's a dark chapter in our history that should not be forgotten, but we must learn from the mistakes made during that time.