YouTube Carnival Magic is an event that takes place on the popular video sharing platform, YouTube. It is a celebration of creativity, entertainment, and community, bringing together content creators, viewers, and fans from all over the world. During this event, YouTube holds various activities and showcases the talents of its creators, providing them with a platform to share their work with a wider audience. The **main idea** behind YouTube Carnival Magic is to highlight the diverse and talented community of YouTube creators. It serves as a way to recognize their contributions, as well as give them an opportunity to connect with their fans in person. The event features live performances, panel discussions, workshops, and meet and greets with creators, allowing fans to engage with their favorite YouTubers on a more personal level.
During the VIP event at 12:15PM(45 min before the drafts were to start), they sent out an e-mail stating that there would be “free on-demand drafts in the Black Lotus VIP lounge from 1:00 – 4:00 PM today!” Please join us after your VIP event to participate. Draft product will be from recent Magic: The Gathering sets and limited to two drafts per person.” The issue is this was way last minute and during the exclusive VIP sealed event. A lot of people don’t have e-mails pushed to their phone and missed out on it if they didn’t happen to go into the lounge later that day. I only knew about it because I walked by the lounge and one of the staff members outside told me to check my e-mail. What happened when showed up is they crossed our name off a list, gave up 6 packs of Dominaria Remastered draft boosters and said to the effect of “you can play or not, do whatever”. It wasn’t really planned, no one was running it. We would have to form the pods and do logistics ourselves after just handing out the packs. Everyone took the packs and there was no drafting done since quite a few people still needed to go back to the tournament floor to finish the last two rounds of the VIP sealed event.
One 1 Best in Show Award US 4,000 cash prize, two 2 Three-Day VIP badges to our final Festival event in 2023, and one 1 hotel room to be used at the event. While most people weren t expecting a Magic 30 box, most were at least expecting something like an exclusive printing of a card or something similar just for the VIP attendees.
The event features live performances, panel discussions, workshops, and meet and greets with creators, allowing fans to engage with their favorite YouTubers on a more personal level. One of the most exciting aspects of YouTube Carnival Magic is the opportunity to witness some of the platform's biggest stars perform live. From musicians and dancers to comedians and vloggers, creators from various genres come together to showcase their skills and entertain the audience.
MagicCon Philadelphia 2023 Black Lotus VIP critique with pictures
EDIT 9/27/23: The post about Las Vegas can be found at https://old.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/16tmj5p/magiccon_las_vegas_2023_black_lotus_vip_critique/ ?
I arrived at the convention center early to check out the lay of the land. I also wanted to take pictures of the Black Lotus VIP lounge since it appears no one else has done that at previous con’s or Magicfests so people could see what it’s like. From what I was told, there were about 350 Black Lotus VIP badges sold for this event. Every single person I talked to who had the VIP badge here said that after this event they will not be buying it again and will tell others not to but it into the future because it’s not worth it unless changes are made to the experience. Link to pictures: https://imgur.com/gallery/KHE0RNU
The VIP Lounge / play area
When I arrived I was very disappointed in the lounge itself. It was very sparse. The tables had no covers with bare plywood and heads of screws exposed, in the room was coffee, hot water, and a 5-gallon water dispenser. They had Earl Gray tea to go with the hot water. There was an empty bowl of popcorn and no other drinks/food for the rest of the day. It was the same on Saturday, except there was about a dozen small bags of chips, a small bags of nuts, and a handful of candy bars. At about 3PM on Saturday some cookies, brownies, and cans of soda were brought out. The lounge closed at 7PM so this was already most of the way through the day. On Sunday morning, we finally had table covers on the table and the snacks/sodas weren’t stocked until around noon. There were never any restocks of the snacks or drinks that I saw and they went pretty quickly. The VIP play area was a decently sized roped off section on the main trade show floor near the command zone. However with it being a distance from the lounge, I almost never saw anyone in there and there were no special events in that area.
On Saturday when they didn’t have food or drink in the VIP area, the staff had a few convention food vouchers to give out. However they only had about 8-10 of them which wasn’t even enough for everyone sitting in the lounge at that time.
This is in contrast to MagicCon Vegas where the VIP lounge had coolers with Monster Energy drinks and sodas in them, and they were replenished throughout the day so they were always available. The VIP play area in Vegas was also located in the lounge itself. In Philly, there was a free-play area right next to the VIP lounge and that could have easily been used as the VIP play area if they just merged the two by moving the dividers. One staff member mentioned on Sunday that later that day it was/being turned into a VIP play area(more on that later).
The VIP Experience (intangibles)
We were permitted to enter the official merchandise store 30 min before the rest of the attendees at 9:30am to get our shopping done early. However, Exhibitors(card stores with booth space) were also admitted to the hall early to get their booths set up and they had already formed a line in-front of us to buy product to bring back to their booths and home with them to sell later. We had our own VIP line but a lot of them were able to place their orders before we were able to do so negating this benefits value.
On at least Saturday and Sunday morning, Mark Rosewater came in the VIP lounge and answered questions / signed cards. He stayed until people didn’t have anything else to sign and everyone ran out of questions. He even calling out a few times before he left if anyone else would like anything signed or if anyone had any other questions. Aaron Forsythe was also in there for a short time. There was apparently an art director who worked at least a little bit in the VIP lounge but no one knew he was an art director so no questions were really asked about art. I don’t know if there were other official WOTC staff working or if the rest were all contractors. I didn’t see or hear about any of the hired cosplayers in the VIP area until Sunday(more on that later).
The VIP party was decent. It was held at an art gallery where there were quite a few original arts on display. Mark Rosewater was here too answering questions. Gavin Verhey was inside for a hot minute. There were some other employees of Wizards, but I didn’t know who they were. The Professor Onyx cosplayer was in attendance and I think one other was too but I don’t remember. It was nice to spend a little time there and have your two drinks which were included.
John Avon had two times reserved on Sunday where he did signing sessions just for the VIP attendees. 10:00AM – 12:00PM and 4:30PM to 5:30PM. The first one was right before and during the VIP sealed event and the second was after most people had left the con to go home. From what I understand of him, this was most likely his idea because he is all about the fans and doesn’t want anyone thinking they had a bad experience with him.
Kudos to Mark Rosewater and John Avon.
The VIP Swag (tangibles)
We did get what they said we would get when signing up for the event and that was it. The consensus among badge holders was that nothing at the con really made us feel like VIP’s with the VIP SWAG. Some people were expecting more things as unannounced items like at MagicCon Vegas. In Vegas they received a Richard Garfield PH.d signed card and a box of Magic 30. One person I talked to got the Black Lotus package only because they thought they would get the Magic 30 box, but myself and everyone else assumed it was a marketing promotion to try to hype it up before it went on sale and we were not expecting to get boxes or packs of it. Everything we received except for the backpack and Arcane Signet cards could have been purchased at the con for much less than we paid for this badge. The staff also told us to double check the contents right away because about 25% of the bags were mis-packed. If you did have an issue the staff in the VIP lounge couldn’t help you right here. They had to instruct you to go to the Reed Exhibition(trade show coordinator company) info desk and talk to them about it. While most people weren’t expecting a Magic 30 box, most were at least expecting something like an exclusive printing of a card or something similar just for the VIP attendees.
Sunday:
We had the VIP event on Sunday morning. It was Dominaria Remastered sealed. They also gave out three different collector boosters as swag for attending, but you couldn’t use them in your decks. Also really nice is the prize points were doubled compared to other events. They also stated that if you 3-0 you get a secret prize. They wouldn’t tell us what it was until someone did go 3-0. It ended up being a Traditional Foil “Just some totally normal guys” secret lair.
It also seems that staff may have been listening to some of our complaints during the con that they basically “phoned in” the VIP experience compared to the Vegas and tried to make up for it. But they failed pretty hard at this. People who attended both Vegas and here as VIP’s said in Vegas that WOTC staff would come randomly multiple times per day with packs and just start doing events in the lounge/play area with people there.
During the VIP event at 12:15PM(45 min before the drafts were to start), they sent out an e-mail stating that there would be “free on-demand drafts in the Black Lotus VIP lounge from 1:00 – 4:00 PM today!” Please join us after your VIP event to participate. Draft product will be from recent Magic: The Gathering sets and limited to two drafts per person.” The issue is this was way last minute and during the exclusive VIP sealed event. A lot of people don’t have e-mails pushed to their phone and missed out on it if they didn’t happen to go into the lounge later that day. I only knew about it because I walked by the lounge and one of the staff members outside told me to check my e-mail. What happened when showed up is they crossed our name off a list, gave up 6 packs of Dominaria Remastered draft boosters and said to the effect of “you can play or not, do whatever”. It wasn’t really planned, no one was running it. We would have to form the pods and do logistics ourselves after just handing out the packs. Everyone took the packs and there was no drafting done since quite a few people still needed to go back to the tournament floor to finish the last two rounds of the VIP sealed event.
They also brought the cosplayers Professor Onyx, Chandra, Garruk, and a Phyrexian to the lounge in the afternoon for what I believe was the first and only time during the con to interact and take pictures with the VIP attendees.
Miscellaneous
During the con very a limited edition Secret Lair Shivan Dragon card with art from a very popular artist was given away randomly by staff. https://www.reddit.com/r/magicTCG/comments/114se25/sld_shivan_dragon/ to my knowledge and asking others, none of these at all were given away in the VIP lounge. So we paying $700 for access to private lounge which by being there was supposedly to relax away from the show floor and this caused us to miss out chances on obtaining one of these cards. The consensus from badge holders is that this didn’t seem much like a VIP experience to us.
We had starting letting staff know that we weren’t happy with the VIP experience and people who were at both Vegas and here were mentioning the differences. During one of these conversations a staff member said that the higher ups were seeing the VIP experience as being better at Vegas based on the metrics they follow. This flabbergasted us who were involved in this conversation. I asked what metrics they were using and they said it was issues with bags, the VIP event starting on time, etc. I asked if badge holder satisfaction was a metric they were measuring and I was told that it wasn’t.
Staff
On a bright note, the ones we interacted with directly were great and none of us had complaints about them. They helped out as much as they could and at least from what we saw, tried to be advocates for us because they also didn’t like what they saw going on for how much we paid for the badges.
Conclusion
Overall, every single person who I talked to who had a VIP badge said that they did not find value in it over standard access to the con. The lounge wasn’t really worth it because the convention space was so large that there was always space on the show floor to sit at a table by yourself if you wanted. Except for the backpack(nothing really special in it) and Arcane Signet cards, everything else could have been purchased for retail for much less than the extra price for the badge.
From what we were told the metrics they use were showing that this was a better VIP experience than Vegas, but those metrics don’t take into account the most important metric; customer satisfaction, and that was very low from everyone I spoke with. I mentioned that people buy the VIP badges based off the experiences of people at the previous con. As of right now, not one VIP badge holder who attended Philly is suggesting that anyone get the VIP package in the future Magiccon’s unless changes are made in the experience.
If anyone from Wizards is reading this, I am in marketing & have years of experience planning trade/consumer shows in the course of my employment, so I have experience here. Please DM me if you would like to have a conversation to improve the experience for the future. We had discussions in the lounge of other intangibles / low cost ideas that would make people feel more like VIP’s and feel like they got the value for what we paid for and doesn’t eat into your bottom line from the badge sales. I have purposefully left these out of this post because some of them wouldn’t really be understood unless you went through the experience we did in Vegas and at Philly. Also, if you do decide to do something like a special card or something to try to make up for the disappointing VIP experience in Philly and vastly different VIP experiences between Vegas and Philly, you have our mailing addresses.
Overall, every single person who I talked to who had a VIP badge said that they did not find value in it over standard access to the con. The lounge wasn’t really worth it because the convention space was so large that there was always space on the show floor to sit at a table by yourself if you wanted. Except for the backpack(nothing really special in it) and Arcane Signet cards, everything else could have been purchased for retail for much less than the extra price for the badge.
The event also hosts interactive workshops where attendees can learn from these creators and gain insights into their creative processes. Moreover, YouTube Carnival Magic is a great platform for creators to collaborate with each other and form new partnerships. The event encourages networking and fosters a sense of community among creators, enabling them to share ideas, collaborate on projects, and support each other's work. Since its inception, YouTube Carnival Magic has grown in popularity and has become a highly anticipated event for both creators and fans. It serves as a testament to the power of YouTube as a platform for creativity, entertainment, and community. Through this event, YouTube continues to celebrate and empower its creators, providing them with opportunities to shine and connecting them with their dedicated fanbase. In conclusion, YouTube Carnival Magic is an exciting celebration of creativity and community on the popular video platform, YouTube. It brings together content creators, viewers, and fans from all over the world, offering a platform for creators to showcase their work and connect with their audience. The event features live performances, workshops, and networking opportunities, allowing creators to collaborate and fans to engage with their favorite YouTubers. It's an event that celebrates the power of YouTube as a platform for creativity, entertainment, and community..
Reviews for "Carnival Magic Inspiration: Youtube's Best Moments"
1. John - ★☆☆☆☆
I was highly disappointed with the "Youtube carnival magic" show. I found it to be unoriginal and uninspiring. The tricks performed were ones I had seen countless times before on other channels, and there was nothing that set it apart from the rest. The performer lacked charisma and failed to engage the audience. Overall, it was a major letdown and not worth the time or money.
2. Sarah - ★★☆☆☆
I had high expectations for the "Youtube carnival magic" show, but unfortunately, it fell short for me. While the tricks were well-executed technically, I found them to be lacking in creativity and imagination. The overall presentation felt rushed and the performer seemed disconnected from the audience. The show lacked the wow-factor that I was hoping for and left me feeling underwhelmed.
3. Michael - ★★☆☆☆
I attended the "Youtube carnival magic" show with high hopes, considering the positive reviews I had heard. However, I was left feeling disappointed. The tricks were predictable and the performance lacked energy. It felt like the performer was going through the motions without any real enthusiasm. I was expecting to be amazed and entertained, but unfortunately, I left the show feeling unimpressed.
4. Emily - ★☆☆☆☆
I regret spending my money on the "Youtube carnival magic" show. The tricks were cliché and lacked any element of surprise. The performer seemed disengaged and didn't make an effort to connect with the audience. It felt like watching a mediocre street magic performance rather than a captivating show. I wouldn't recommend wasting your time or money on this uninspiring spectacle.