Shapeshifting as a Metaphor: Symbolism in the Transformation Witch Trials

The transformation witch trials were a series of events in the 16th and 17th centuries where individuals accused of practicing witchcraft were subject to trials and often execution. These trials were characterized by a belief in the power of witches to transform into animals or other forms and cause harm to others. During this time period, the belief in witches and witchcraft was widespread, and people often looked for someone to blame when faced with hardships or misfortunes. Accusations of witchcraft were frequently made against marginalized individuals, such as widows, the elderly, and those who were seen as different or using unconventional practices. One prominent example of a transformation witch trial occurred in the town of Salem, Massachusetts in 1692. This was a time of intense religious fervor, and a group of young girls began exhibiting unusual behavior, claiming to be possessed by witches.

Sandra Harding - Emeritus Professor of Philosophy, University of California at Los Angeles

Renana Jhabvala - Chairperson, SEWA Bharat All India SEWA , Member, UN Secretary General s High Level Panel on Women s Economic Empowerment in 2016 2017; Chairperson, WIEGO Women in Informal Employment Globalizing and Organizing. excellent analysis and new insights of critical importance to policymakers in Africa on a human rights issue affecting women and the elderly in Africa.

This was a time of intense religious fervor, and a group of young girls began exhibiting unusual behavior, claiming to be possessed by witches. This sparked a wave of accusations and trials, resulting in the execution of multiple people, mostly women. The trials were conducted in a highly biased manner, with often flimsy evidence and reliance on spectral evidence, which involved the testimonies of those claiming to have been harmed by witches in their transformed states.

Witch Hunts

Mezzadri, Alessandra 2022. The Social Reproduction of Pandemic Surplus Populations and Global Development Narratives on Inequality and Informal Labour. Development and Change, Vol. 53, Issue. 6, p. 1230.

Gershman, Boris 2022. Witchcraft Beliefs Around the World: An Exploratory Analysis. SSRN Electronic Journal ,

Gershman, Boris and Proto, Eugenio 2022. Witchcraft beliefs around the world: An exploratory analysis. PLOS ONE, Vol. 17, Issue. 11, p. e0276872.

Nathan, Dev Kelkar, Govind and Govindnathan, Pallavi 2022. Knowledge economy and gender inequality. Gender, Technology and Development, Vol. 26, Issue. 3, p. 341.

Kelkar, Govind Sinha, Sarika and Nathan, Dev 2022. Social Exclusion and Policies of Inclusion. p. 93.

Peacey, Sarah Campbell, Olympia L. K. and Mace, Ruth 2022. Same-sex competition and sexual conflict expressed through witchcraft accusations. Scientific Reports, Vol. 12, Issue. 1,

Brunnekreef, Jolanda 2023. “The Witch’s Mirror”: A Review of Scholarship on Witchcraft and a Reassessment Based on the Intersectional Lived Experiences of Dalits and Adivasis. Religions, Vol. 14, Issue. 3, p. 401.

Nathan, Dev Rahul S. and Kelkar, Govind 2023. After the Long Walk Home…the Gendered Rural Safety Net. Agrarian South: Journal of Political Economy: A triannual Journal of Agrarian South Network and CARES, Vol. 12, Issue. 2, p. 227.

Amo-Adjei, Joshua Essuman, Ruth Nurzhynska, Anastasiia Deliege, Antoine Sharma, Geeta Iddrisu, Iddi Nikoi, Charity and Rao, Chythra R. 2023. Experiences of parents and stakeholders in caring for, and supporting children with special needs in Ghana. PLOS ONE, Vol. 18, Issue. 3, p. e0281502.

Govind Kelkar , Landesa Rural Development Institute, New Delhi , Dev Nathan , Institute of Human Development, New Delhi

• Publisher: Cambridge University Press
• Online publication date: May 2020
• Print publication year: 2020
• Online ISBN: 9781108781091
• DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108490511

• Subjects: Sociology of Gender, Social and Cultural Anthropology, Anthropology, Sociology

Email your librarian or administrator to recommend adding this book to your organisation's collection.

• Govind Kelkar , Dev Nathan

• Online ISBN: 9781108781091
• Book DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108490511

Book description

Witch hunts are the result of gendered, cultural and socioeconomic struggles over acute structural, economic and social transformations in both the formation of gendered class societies and that of patriarchal capitalism. This book combines political economy with gender and cultural analysis to explain the articulation of cultural beliefs about women as causing harm, and struggles over patriarchy in periods of structural economic transformation. It brings in field data from India and South-East Asia and incorporates a large body of works on witch hunts across geographies and histories. Witch Hunts is a scholarly analysis of the human rights violation of women and its correction through changes in beliefs, knowledge practices and adaptation in structural transformation.

Reviews

‘It is interesting, important and well grounded in both older and newer approaches to witchcraft. The general argument about witchcraft, gender, patriarchy and structural changes in the economy is also quite persuasive, though I am sure there will be quibbles. From my point of view, the book looks both original and important.'

Arjun Appadurai - New York University

‘Very impressive! The authors manage to cover a lot of ground. Am really impressed by the wide scope of the book, both because of all the areas and themes covered and because of the authors' wide reading! So many literature references and ideas … I think the focus on witch-hunts is original and productive.'

Peter Geschiere - University of Amsterdam and author of Witchcraft

‘Witch Hunts provides an illuminating exploration of how beliefs in witches function to explain misfortunes, virtually always in the context of significant economic and social transformations. Such processes are routinely gendered, transferring land and social power usually from women to men, and thus creating or strengthening patriarchies. Innovative is that the authors take the standpoint of the victims of witch hunts in accounting for such practices and beliefs. Decades of field work in India, and archival resources from primarily Africa and early modern Europe, provide the solid evidential basis for analyses of similarities and differences between witch hunts across geographies and histories. Clearly written and well-organized, this will make fascinating reading for courses in history, economics, anthropology and women's studies.'

Sandra Harding - Emeritus Professor of Philosophy, University of California at Los Angeles

‘A fascinating account, in horrifying detail, of the under-side of community and family life. We see patriarchy at its worst in this book which is an expert analysis of the socio-economic reasons for the treatment of women as witches, but with rays of hope on societal mechanisms which prevent or punish perpetrators. Highly recommended as it is both moving and knowledgeable.'

Renana Jhabvala - Chairperson, SEWA Bharat (All India SEWA), Member, UN Secretary General's High Level Panel on Women's Economic Empowerment in 2016–2017; Chairperson, WIEGO (Women in Informal Employment: Globalizing and Organizing)

‘. excellent analysis and new insights of critical importance to policymakers in Africa on a human rights issue affecting women and the elderly in Africa.'

Sheila Oparaocha - ENERGIA International

‘Based on field work data on India and drawing on voluminous body of works on witchcraft and witch hunt across geography and history beyond continents and across disciplines and perspectives, Govind Kelkar and Dev Nathan lay bare general principles that produce, reinforce and weaken witch hunts in societies. This they do by brilliant engagement with three critical factors of witchcraft belief, gender struggle and socio-economic transformation by combining the lens of political economy with cultural analysis. Large in canvas, comparative in perspective and refreshing in analysis, the book will enrich anyone interested in issues of gender, witch hunts, socio-economic transformation, political economy and indigenous peoples.'

Virginius Xaxa - former Professor of Sociology, Delhi School of Economics

‘…Witch Hunts represents an important contribution to the literature. … the book points to several promising avenues for further research that will hopefully be pursued by the authors and those inspired by their work.'

Boris Gershman Source: Journal of Development Studies

‘Witch Hunts provides an illuminating exploration of how beliefs in witches function to explain misfortunes, virtually always in the context of significant economic and social transformations. Such processes are routinely gendered, transferring land and social power usually from women to men, and thus creating or strengthening patriarchies. Innovative is that the authors take the standpoint of the victims of witch hunts in accounting for such practices and beliefs. Decades of field work in India, and archival resources from primarily Africa and early modern Europe, provide the solid evidential basis for analyses of similarities and differences between witch hunts across geographies and histories. Clearly written and well-organized, this will make fascinating reading for courses in history, economics, anthropology and women's studies.'

The accused were often subjected to harsh interrogation methods, such as being deprived of sleep or subjected to physical torture, in order to extract confessions. The transformation witch trials have become a symbol of the dangers of mass hysteria and the consequences of unfounded beliefs. They serve as a reminder of the importance of due process and the potential for individuals to be unjustly persecuted in times of fear and suspicion. In modern times, the transformation witch trials have been widely criticized and seen as a dark chapter in history. Efforts have been made to commemorate the victims and learn from the mistakes of the past. The lessons from these trials continue to inform discussions on topics such as mob mentality, the power of belief, and the importance of fairness and justice in legal systems..

Reviews for "Victims and Perpetrators: Unraveling the Identities in the Transformation Witch Trials"

1. John - 1/5 stars - This book was a complete waste of my time. The plot was confusing and poorly developed, and the characters were one-dimensional and unlikable. The writing style was also difficult to follow, with long, convoluted sentences that left me feeling frustrated. I was hoping for an engaging and thrilling story, but unfortunately, "Transformation Witch Trial" fell flat in all aspects. I would not recommend this book to anyone.

2. Sarah - 2/5 stars - "Transformation Witch Trial" had the potential to be an interesting read, but it failed to deliver. The pacing was slow, and the story lacked depth, leaving me feeling unsatisfied. The characters were forgettable, and their motivations were often unclear. The author attempted to incorporate magical elements, but they felt forced and did not add any real intrigue to the plot. Overall, I found this book to be mediocre and not worth the time invested.

3. Emma - 1/5 stars - I found "Transformation Witch Trial" to be incredibly disappointing. The storyline was riddled with clichés and predictable twists, making it difficult to stay engaged. The writing was also lackluster, with minimal description and an abundance of grammatical errors. The dialogue felt forced and unnatural, further detracting from the reading experience. I was hoping for a captivating and fresh take on witch trials, but this book fell short on all accounts. I would not recommend it to anyone seeking an exciting and well-written read.

4. Michael - 2/5 stars - "Transformation Witch Trial" had an interesting concept but failed to deliver a satisfying execution. The plot was confusing and lacked coherence, making it hard to follow along. The characters were underdeveloped and lacked depth, causing me to feel detached from their struggles and emotions. Furthermore, certain elements of the story felt contrived and unrealistic, leading to a less immersive reading experience. Overall, while the premise was intriguing, the poor execution left me feeling disappointed and unfulfilled.

Transformation Witch Trials: Exploring the Cultural and Historical Context