Reevaluating Cotton Mather's Role in the Witch Hunts of Salem

Cotton Mather, a prominent Puritan minister and writer, played a significant role in the persecution of witches in Salem, Massachusetts, during the late 17th century. Born in 1663, Mather was raised in a highly religious household and inherited a strong belief in the existence of witchcraft. In 1689, he published a book called "Memorable Providences Relating to Witchcraft and Possessions," which recounted various cases of witchcraft and demonic possession. This work helped shape public opinion and fuel the hysteria surrounding witchcraft in the region. Mather's involvement in the Salem witch trials became more pronounced in 1692 when a series of strange events involving young girls began to unfold in the town. These girls, including his own niece, claimed to be possessed by witches and started accusing several individuals of practicing witchcraft.

The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica This article was most recently revised and updated by Melissa Petruzzello.

As the trials progressed, and growing numbers of person confessed to being witches, Mather became firmly convinced that an Army of Devils is horribly broke in upon the place which is our center. His Manuductio ad Ministerium 1726 was a handbook of advice for young graduates to the ministry on doing good, on college love affairs, on poetry and music, and on style.

These girls, including his own niece, claimed to be possessed by witches and started accusing several individuals of practicing witchcraft. Mather, considering this as evidence of the devil's presence in Salem, actively promoted the trials and supported the judicial process that led to the execution of 20 people. His influential position in the community and his strong belief in the existence of witches provided legitimacy to the accusations and fueled the fervor to identify and eliminate witches from society.

Cotton Mather

While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions.

Our editors will review what you’ve submitted and determine whether to revise the article.

• The University of Virginia - Salem Witch Trials - Cotton Mather
• Famous Trials - Cotton Mather

While every effort has been made to follow citation style rules, there may be some discrepancies. Please refer to the appropriate style manual or other sources if you have any questions.

Our editors will review what you’ve submitted and determine whether to revise the article.

• The University of Virginia - Salem Witch Trials - Cotton Mather
• Famous Trials - Cotton Mather

Encyclopaedia Britannica's editors oversee subject areas in which they have extensive knowledge, whether from years of experience gained by working on that content or via study for an advanced degree. They write new content and verify and edit content received from contributors.

Cotton Mather, (born February 12, 1663, Boston, Massachusetts Bay Colony [U.S.]—died February 13, 1728, Boston), American Congregational minister and author, supporter of the old order of the ruling clergy, who became the most celebrated of all New England Puritans. He combined a mystical strain (he believed in the existence of witchcraft) with a modern scientific interest (he supported smallpox inoculation).

The son of Increase Mather and the grandson of John Cotton and Richard Mather, Cotton Mather lived all his life in Boston. He entered Harvard at the age of 12, easily passing entrance requirements to read and write Latin and to “decline the Greek nouns and verbs.” He devoted himself unremittingly to study and prayer. At 18 he received his M.A. degree from the hands of his father, who was president of the college.

Mather once noted that his life was “a continual conversation with heaven,” but he spent agonizing hours convinced that he was damned and equal time in ecstasies that he was not. For a while, he feared he could not enter the ministry because of a speech impediment, and he considered becoming a physician; the subject of medicine was of lifelong interest to him. After a friend persuaded him “to oblige himself to a dilated Deliberation in speaking,” he conquered his weakness and returned to religious studies. He preached his first sermon in his father’s church in August 1680 and in October another from his grandfather John Cotton’s pulpit. He was formally ordained in 1685 and became his father’s colleague.

He devoted his life to praying, preaching, writing, and publishing and still followed his main purpose in life of doing good. His book, Bonifacius, or Essays to Do Good (1710), instructs others in humanitarian acts, some ideas being far ahead of his time: the schoolmaster to reward instead of punish his students, the physician to study the state of mind of his patient as a probable cause of illness. He established societies for community projects.

He joined his father in cautioning judges against the use of “spectre evidence” (testimony of a victim of witchcraft that he had been attacked by a spectre bearing the appearance of someone he knew) in the witchcraft trials and in working for the ouster of Sir Edmund Andros as governor of Massachusetts. He was also a leader in the fight for inoculation against smallpox, incurring popular disapproval. He was introduced to the idea by Onesimus, an enslaved West African man in his household. When Cotton inoculated his own son, who almost died from it, the whole community was wrathful, and a bomb was thrown through his chamber window. Satan seemed on the side of his enemies; various members of his family became ill, and some died. Worst of all, his son Increase was arrested for rioting.

Mather’s interest in science and particularly in various American phenomena—published in his Curiosa Americana (1712–24)—won him membership in the Royal Society of London. His account of the inoculation episode was published in the society’s transactions. He corresponded extensively with notable scientists, such as Robert Boyle. His Christian Philosopher (1721) recognizes God in the wonders of the earth and the universe beyond; it is both philosophical and scientific and, ironically, anticipates 18th-century Deism, despite his clinging to the old order.

Mather was not against the institution of slavery, and he enslaved a number of people in his household. Many Puritans, including members of his own congregation, actively participated in slave trafficking and were involved in the selling of Native Americans overseas and the importation of Africans. He defended the practice as being biblically rooted and famously asserted that the souls of black-skinned slaves were washed white with baptism and that they become “the Free-men of the Lord” while still enslaved (A Good Master Well Served: A Brief Discourse on the Necessary Properties & Practices of a Good Servant in Every-Kind of Servitude [1696]). In The Negro Christianized (1706), a pamphlet widely attributed to Mather, he urged slave-owners to teach their “servants” Christianity, accepting them as spiritual brethren, and to treat them justly and kindly.

Cotton Mather wrote and published more than 400 works. His magnum opus was Magnalia Christi Americana (1702), an ecclesiastical history of America from the founding of New England to his own time. His Manuductio ad Ministerium (1726) was a handbook of advice for young graduates to the ministry: on doing good, on college love affairs, on poetry and music, and on style. His ambitious 20-year work on biblical learning was interrupted by his death.

He died only five years after his father, whose colleague he had been for 40 years. He was widowed twice and had 15 children by his three wives—Abigail Phillips, Elizabeth (née Clark) Hubbard, and Lydia (née Lee) George—only two survived him.

Cotton Mather’s heritage from his two grandfathers, Richard Mather and John Cotton, was both fortunate and unfortunate. Like them, he had an active mind and the will to use it. He lived in the shadow of their greatness and expected to carry on the tradition and to assume their role in the Puritan community. Unfortunately, he could not see that the old order was passing. As colonial communities became more secure from earlier hardships of settlements, they also became more complacent and less in need of a confining spiritual leadership. Cotton fought for the continuance of the old order of the ruling clergy, sometimes with frustration, sometimes in anger. His Diary was edited by W.C. Ford (1911–12).

The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica This article was most recently revised and updated by Melissa Petruzzello.

Mather's sermons and writings during this period affirmed the reality of witchcraft, further influencing public opinion and allowing the persecution to escalate. However, as the trials continued, doubts started to arise, even among some of Mather's peers. Many began to question the reliability of the spectral evidence presented in the courtroom, which relied heavily on the visions and testimonies of the afflicted girls. Mather, although initially defending the use of spectral evidence, eventually changed his stance and argued for more stringent standards of proof, contributing to the waning of the witch trials. Cotton Mather's involvement in the persecution of witches in Salem exemplifies the religious and social climate of the time. His fervent belief in witchcraft, combined with his influential position, contributed to the escalation of the trials and the subsequent execution of innocent individuals. However, Mather's later change of stance highlights the growing skepticism surrounding the accusations and the eventual decline of the witch trials..

Reviews for "Cotton Mather and the Salem Witch Trials: A Case Study in Mass Hysteria"

1. Sarah - 2 out of 5 stars - I was really disappointed with "Cotton Mather and the Persecution of Witches in Salem." The book seemed incredibly biased and lacked a comprehensive examination of the events surrounding the witch trials. It felt like the author was solely focused on depicting Cotton Mather as the primary instigator, overlooking the complex societal and religious factors that contributed to the hysteria. Overall, this book failed to provide a nuanced and balanced perspective on the Salem witch trials.

2. Michael - 3 out of 5 stars - While I appreciate the effort in shedding light on the role of Cotton Mather in the Salem witch trials, I found this book to be repetitive and overly focused on demonizing him. The author seems more interested in vilifying Mather rather than analyzing the broader context of the events. The lack of exploration of other key figures and societal factors left me feeling unsatisfied and wanting a more comprehensive understanding of the trials.

3. Emily - 2 out of 5 stars - As a history enthusiast, I was excited to dive into "Cotton Mather and the Persecution of Witches in Salem." However, I was left disappointed by the author's lack of thorough research and analysis. The book was riddled with factual errors and questionable interpretations of historical events. Additionally, the writing style was dry and difficult to engage with, making it a tedious read. I would not recommend this book to anyone seeking a well-researched and insightful exploration of the Salem witch trials.

Cotton Mather's Fear of the Devil and Its Connection to the Witch Trials in Salem