The magical outsiders refer to characters in literature and popular culture who possess supernatural abilities or belong to a different realm or world. They are typically portrayed as mysterious and powerful beings who exist outside of the norms of society. These characters often face both admiration and fear from those around them, as their abilities and origins make them different and often misunderstood. One of the most iconic examples of magical outsiders is the character of Harry Potter in J.K. Rowling's Harry Potter series.
It depends what you are trying to do. If you have it up, you must overcome the spell resistance of the summoned creature in order for them not to touch you.
Picture it as the outward version sending out the protective aura and it is diluted by the space it has to fill, while the inward version concentrates the effect, allowing it to hold called creatures. Of course with a generic name like protection from evil or magic circle against evil, thematically it should stop a whole lot of nasty things, but then it gets a little overpowered.
Rowling's Harry Potter series. Harry is a wizard living in the Muggle (non-magical) world, and his ability to perform magic makes him unique and sets him apart from his peers. Throughout the series, Harry struggles with his identity as a wizard and the expectations placed on him, but ultimately embraces his magical abilities and uses them to fight against evil.
Magic Circle keep out called outsiders?
The Magic Circle Against Evil spell hints that it can protect against even outsiders brought to the material plane via a calling effect, though it isn't directly stated.
It is hinted at again in the Core Rulebook and Ultimate Magic under their respective planar binding sections.
So. can a called devil touch someone surrounded by a magic circle against evil or not?
Ravingdork wrote:The Magic Circle Against Evil spell hints that it can protect against even outsiders brought to the material plane via a calling effect, though it isn't directly stated.
It is hinted at again in the Core Rulebook and Ultimate Magic under their respective planar binding sections.
So. can a called devil touch someone surrounded by a magic circle against evil or not?
Any devil with Spell Resistance may make an attempt to bypass the protection. If they do not have spell resistance, then no they cannot even make an attempt.
Ravingdork wrote:The Magic Circle Against Evil spell hints that it can protect against even outsiders brought to the material plane via a calling effect, though it isn't directly stated.
It is hinted at again in the Core Rulebook and Ultimate Magic under their respective planar binding sections.
So. can a called devil touch someone surrounded by a magic circle against evil or not?
It depends what you are trying to do. If you have it up, you must overcome the spell resistance of the summoned creature in order for them not to touch you.
You can also use it in the process of binding an outsider. This time, the spell resistance check is used to see whether or not you can keep the outsider within the circle.
By RAW I would say no, since it only mentions summoned creatures, but thematically I would say it should. Of course with a generic name like protection from evil or magic circle against evil, thematically it should stop a whole lot of nasty things, but then it gets a little overpowered. :)
| 1 person marked this as FAQ candidate. |
By RAW I would say no, since it only mentions summoned creatures, but thematically I would say it should. Of course with a generic name like protection from evil or magic circle against evil, thematically it should stop a whole lot of nasty things, but then it gets a little overpowered. :)
If it doesn't protect against called creatures, than how can it trap called creatures? Seems like a logical disconnect.
Does anybody know developer intent in regards to this matter?
Ravingdork wrote: neonmagician wrote:By RAW I would say no, since it only mentions summoned creatures, but thematically I would say it should. Of course with a generic name like protection from evil or magic circle against evil, thematically it should stop a whole lot of nasty things, but then it gets a little overpowered. :)
If it doesn't protect against called creatures, than how can it trap called creatures? Seems like a logical disconnect.
Does anybody know developer intent in regards to this matter?
Actually, I would think called creatures would fall under the the first two effects of Protection from Evil (I missed the specification of a called creature in the initial post). If cast defensively (or outward per the spell text), it would not block them from contact, but it would be slightly harder for them to make contact.
If the spell is cast inward, you are creating a containment area in essence. However, this must be cast before the creature is called. Basically useful if you are calling up an evil bugger to press them for information.
Picture it as the outward version sending out the protective aura and it is diluted by the space it has to fill, while the inward version concentrates the effect, allowing it to hold called creatures.
Picture it as the outward version sending out the protective aura and it is diluted by the space it has to fill, while the inward version concentrates the effect, allowing it to hold called creatures.
Another famous example is Frodo Baggins from J.R.R. Tolkien's The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Frodo is a hobbit, a small humanoid creature, who embarks on a perilous journey to destroy a powerful magical ring. Along the way, Frodo encounters various magical creatures, such as elves and wizards, who aid him in his quest. Despite his small size and lack of physical strength, Frodo's determination and connection to the magical world make him a key figure in the story. These characters and others like them represent the idea of the outsider, someone who is different and possesses abilities or origins that set them apart from the majority. The motif of the magical outsider is often used to explore themes of identity, belonging, and the power of difference. It serves as a reminder that being different or possessing unique abilities can be both a gift and a burden, and that sometimes, it is those who are different who have the power to change the world..
Reviews for "The Mysteries and Legends of the Magical Outsiders"
1. Amy - 2 stars - I really wanted to like "The Magical Outsiders" but I found it to be incredibly predictable and lacking in originality. The characters seemed one-dimensional and the plot felt like a rehashed version of so many other fantasy novels. The writing style was also a bit too simplistic for my taste, making it difficult for me to fully immerse myself in the story. Overall, I was really disappointed with this book and would not recommend it to others.
2. Tom - 1 star - "The Magical Outsiders" was a complete waste of my time. The plot was all over the place, with random twists and turns that made no sense. The world-building was poorly developed, leaving me with more questions than answers. The characters were forgettable and lacked depth, making it hard to care about what happened to them. The prose was also clunky and awkward, making it a struggle to get through each page. I cannot comprehend how this book has received any positive reviews.
3. Rachel - 2 stars - I was excited to read "The Magical Outsiders" based on the hype surrounding it, but unfortunately, it fell flat for me. The pacing was off, with slow sections that dragged on and rushed moments that left me feeling confused. The dialogue felt forced and unnatural, making it difficult for me to connect with the characters. Additionally, the magic system was poorly explained and inconsistent throughout the book. While some aspects of the story showed potential, they were overshadowed by the book's flaws, ultimately leaving me disappointed.
4. Michael - 1 star - I found "The Magical Outsiders" to be incredibly cliché and unoriginal. The characters were stereotypical and lacked any real depth or development. The plot was predictable and offered no surprises, making it a boring read. Additionally, the writing style was unengaging and failed to draw me into the story. I was not impressed with this book at all and would not recommend it to anyone looking for a fresh and unique fantasy read.