Which witch is which? The English language is known for its many confusing words and spellings, and one of the most famous examples of this confusion is the use of the words "which" and "witch." These two words may sound similar, but they have completely different meanings and uses. The word "which" is a pronoun that is used to ask about or indicate a choice between two or more things. It is often used when there are multiple options available, and the speaker or writer wants to know the specific one that is being referred to. For example, "Which book should I read?" or "Which route should we take?" On the other hand, the word "witch" is a noun that refers to a person, usually female, who practices witchcraft or magic. Witches have been a part of folklore and mythology for centuries, often portrayed as powerful, mystical beings with supernatural abilities.
As it is currently described, H. conica is found on the ground under hardwood and conifer trees in North America, South America, Asia, and Europe. You can find the Witch’s Hat across North America fruiting from early summer through fall, or fall through winter in warmer climates like California. There are usually a few to many of these mushrooms scattered around a small area, so if you see one make sure to look around for more! 1,3
Soon after you collect one of these mushrooms, the stipe usually splits in multiple places and curls back, leaving you with a bunch of stringy sections. I did not believe in this separation until I traveled to the mountains of New Mexico and Colorado in 1997 and saw the wide variety of Hygrophorus species out there-- none looking anything like the brightly colored species we have in the midwest.
Witches have been a part of folklore and mythology for centuries, often portrayed as powerful, mystical beings with supernatural abilities. The image of a witch is commonly associated with a pointed hat, broomstick, and cauldron. Due to their similar pronunciation, these two words are often confused, leading to humorous misunderstandings.
Witch hat musyroom
In keeping with a Halloween theme, this month's fungus is the witch's hat mushroom, Hygrocybe conica, also known as Hygrophorus conicus (more on the taxonomy later). With its orange color and witch hat shape, this mushroom is a natural for Halloween. This fungus is common this time of year in coniferous and mixed conifer/hardwood woods-- we took this picture of mushrooms collected by Bernadette O'Reilly in a mixed pine and scrub red oak forest a couple weeks ago. At least here in the midwestern USA, the further north you go, the more likely you are to find Hygrocybe and Hygrophorus specimens. Hygrocybe and Hygrophorus species are reportedly mycorrhizal with both hardwoods and conifers, although I've yet to see definitive proof. They certainly are difficult to culture, indicating that there's something (essential nutrients?) missing in "normal" media.
You may have learned this species as Hygrophorus conicus, but for many year there Hygrocybe has been segregated from Hygrophorus. I did not believe in this separation until I traveled to the mountains of New Mexico and Colorado in 1997 and saw the wide variety of Hygrophorus species out there-- none looking anything like the brightly colored species we have in the midwest. In the field the distinctions between the genera are pretty clear, with a few exceptions. A third genus Camarophyllus, is also segregated out by some. These genera are placed in the family Hygrophoraceae because of their waxy gills and mycorrhizal habit. My students often have trouble with "waxy." I tell them to think of waxy here as the consistency of soft candle wax, not of hardened cold candles.
These genera, once all placed in the genus Hygrophorus, are now separated from one another on the basis of microscopic characters, primarily the arrangement of the hyphae in the gill trama. The gill trama is the flesh of the gills, underneath the outside layer of basidia and basidiospores. To determine the arrangement of the trama, you should look to see how the hyphae grew out from the center of the mushroom toward the outside. In Hygrocybe the gill trama hyphae are parallel to subparallel. In Hygrophorus the trama is divergent. The arrangement of the trama is considered by most agaricologists to be a very important character at the generic level. In the picture to the left, you can see the parallel trama of Hygrocybe conica and the divergent trama of Hygrophorus russula. The origin of each gill section is to the right, and the end of the gill of each section is to the left. The basidia are borne on the outside of the gills, showing up as a dark, dense area in these sections.
However, lumper that I am, I did not believe the distinction was valid until I went to a foray in 1997 in the mountains of New Mexico and saw many species of Hygrophorus there (we don't have very many of these species in our area). Hygrophorus and Hygrocybe are quite different in stature and overall appearance. Hygrocybe species tend to be more brightly colored and much smaller, although there are some bright white Hygrocybe species bigger than any Hygrophorus I've ever seen. Hygrophorus species tend to have more muted colors and are much larger. If you are a "lumper," you might still consider that all these species belong in a single genus, Hygrophorus. Bill Cibula (now retired from NASA) worked on the carotenoid pigments in these genera many years ago, although little of it is yet published. Someone also needs to work on the DNA of these organisms. Taxonomy is often a matter of opinion anyway.
There are many other species of Hygrocybe , ranging in color from red to yellow to orange to white. To the left is Hygrocybe psittacina, the parrot mushroom, so named because of the green color fading out to yellow as it ages. There are many other species of Hygrocybe that may litter the ground, especially in conifer areas.
Below is Hygrophorus russula, our most common Hygrophorus in the midwestern USA. The epithet names comes from the superficial similarity of its fruiting bodies to those of Russula. Note the more muted coloration compared to the Hygrocybe specimens. You probably can't tell from this picture, but these specimens are ten times larger than any of the Hygrocybe species pictured on this page. However, there certainly are a wide variety of colors and sizes represented in each of the genera. Be on the lookout for them in your area.
I hope you enjoyed learning something about Hygrocybe conica. And I hope you have a Happy Halloween. Maybe you should incorporate a mushroom into your Halloween costume? I'd love to see a picture if you do. I'll even include it online if you give me permission to do so.
- Tremella mesenterica, witch's butter.
- Claviceps purpurea, cause of the plant disease ergot and likely factor in the Salem Witch Trials
- Omphalotus olearius, the Jack-O-Lantern Mushroom.
One example of this confusion is the phrase "which witch is which?" This phrase is often used to express confusion or uncertainty when differentiating between two or more similar things or people. For example, if you see two people wearing the same outfit, you might ask, "Which witch is which?" In conclusion, it is important to pay attention to the context and spelling of words like "which" and "witch" to avoid confusion. While "which" is used to indicate choices, "witch" refers to a magical practitioner. Remembering the difference between these two words can help avoid confusion and ensure effective communication..
Reviews for "From kitchen witches to ceremonial witches: The diverse practices within the witchcraft community"
1. Olivia - 1/5 - I found "Which Witch is Which" to be incredibly confusing and poorly written. The plot seemed convoluted and lacked coherence, making it difficult for me to follow along. The characters were also poorly developed, with shallow personalities and inconsistent behavior. Additionally, the writing style was monotonous and lacked any real depth or emotion. Overall, I was highly disappointed with this book and would not recommend it to others.
2. Ethan - 2/5 - "Which Witch is Which" had an interesting premise, but failed to deliver an engaging story. The pacing was extremely slow, and I found myself losing interest multiple times throughout the book. The author tried to incorporate multiple twists and turns, but they felt forced and predictable. The dialogue was also stilted and unnatural, making it difficult for me to connect with any of the characters. Overall, this book lacked the excitement and intrigue I was expecting, and I wouldn't recommend it to others.
3. Emma - 2/5 - I had high hopes for "Which Witch is Which" based on the initially captivating synopsis, but unfortunately, it fell short of my expectations. The world-building was vague and poorly executed, leaving me with many unanswered questions and confusion. The main characters were unrelatable and lacked depth, making it difficult for me to invest in their journey. The writing style was also bland and lacked creativity, making the reading experience dull and unengaging. Overall, I was disappointed with this book and wouldn't recommend it to fellow readers.